4 ms·
If you are in the United States, and are truly a contractor rather than an employee [1], and there is nothing in your contract that specifically says you are ma
by tzs 9y ago
If you are in the United States, and are truly a contractor rather than an employee [1], and there is nothing in your contract that specifically says you are making a "work for hire", then you almost certainly do own the copyrights.
If you author a work, copyright only goes to whoever paid you if either (1) you are an employee and work is created within the scope of your employment, or (2) you are not an employee but it is a "work for hire".
For a work to be a work for hire, there are three requirements that all must be satisfied.
1. The work must be specially ordered or commissioned.
2. There must be a written contract that states it is a work for hire.
3. It must fall into one of nine categories:
• a contribution to a collective work
• a translation
• a part of a motion picture or other audiovisual work
• a supplementary work (e.g., foreword, illustration, editorial notes)
• a compilation
• an instructional text
• a test
• answer material for a test
• an atlas
A bit of Googling turns up a few articles from IP and business law firms saying that most software does not fall under any of these categories and so cannot be a work for hire [2]. On the other hand, there are at least four district court cases that have concluded that software can fall under compilations and under contributions to collective works [3] and so can be works for hire. (But remember, even if in a particular case your software does fall under one of those categories, without the contract saying in writing that it is a work for hire it isn't, and so you retain the copyright).
Probably the best approach, if you want your client to own the copyright, is to include in the contract that you assign the copyright to the client. There is some sample language for a contract copyright assignment in [2].
[1] Whether you are an employee or a contractor for purposes of copyright law is determined by the common law of agency rather than by what your employment contract says. A court would look at how much control the employer has over how the work is done, where it is done, the equipment used to do the work, the scheduling, what other work you can do at the same time, and similar factors.
[2] http://ccbjournal.com/articles/9954/work-hire-doctrine-almost-never-works-software-development-contracts http://ccbjournal.com/articles/9954/work-hire-doctrine-almos...
[3] https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=59a4a8c4-c446-4870-8710-5463bd8ea894 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=59a4a8c4-c446...