3 ms·
I think you've nearly defined "law" out of existence? Law doesn't work like math or computer code. It's always subject to interpretation and lawyers will genera
by skybrian 9y ago
I think you've nearly defined "law" out of existence? Law doesn't work like math or computer code. It's always subject to interpretation and lawyers will generally give you advice about what to expect based on experience, not guarantees.
There are some areas more settled than others, but this is a continuum, not a crisp boundary.
- tripletao 9y agoI certainly agree that it's a continuum, and that an attempt to remove all judicial discretion will yield an impossibly long law still full of loopholes. (As an aside, I think this is why cryptographic smart contracts are grossly oversold.) The GDPR just seems unusually close to the lawless edge of that continuum by the standards of a Western legal system, considering the vagueness of the rules and the severity of the statutory punishments--20M EUR for a small company is a corporate death penalty. But again, you don't need law to do business. I can visit countries where people face the literal human death penalty with negligible due process, and still feel quite confident that I'll be fine. By the standards of worldwide lawlessness, the GDPR is great; but that's a pretty pathetic standard.
- repolfx 9y agoThat's true but a part of the general political tension between parties is, at least in theory, to what extent law is interpreted by judges vs written by politicians. The theory is that laws should be written by politicians and merely applied to specific cases by judges, because politicians are accountable and judges are not. When you have laws that state virtually nothing and rely entirely on interpretation, that's the same thing as moving power away from elected political bodies and into unaccountable elites. This is, not coincidentally, exactly what the entire EU project seems to be constantly engaged in, so it's perhaps no surprise that the EU particularly enjoys passing vague laws that move power away from national politicians and towards the Commission and ECJ (the ECJ judges are appointed by the same process that decides the makeup of the Commission).
- dragonwriter 9y ago> That's true but a part of the general political tension between parties is, at least in theory, to what extent law is interpreted by judges vs written by politicians. In the US, at least, that's true in the rhetoric of one of the parties, but the opposing party doesn't argue the opposite side, just argues that the side that claims it is an issue is hypocritical in its rhetorical stance.