3 ms·
> they're willing to give them up Sure. But why are alternatives so scarce or difficult? Because federal and state governments are going out of their way to a
by superkuh 8y ago
> they're willing to give them up
Sure. But why are alternatives so scarce or difficult?
Because federal and state governments are going out of their way to attack any non-banklike means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency. From heavy regulation (see: New York) to arbitrary abuse of unrelated regulation in form of police action (localbitcoin sellers atttacked and jailed under KYC). This funnels people into players that are willing to bend over for the establishment like Coinbase.
- PeterisP 8y agoYou have a really good point there, the situation is not really indicative of a free choice to give up anonymity but rather of a somewhat forced choice between a 'law-abiding' service versus an 'outlaw' service model that has less restrictions but gets harassed by the authorities. However, for the majority of people, obeying local laws (including AML/KYC regulations) is simply a part of their normal not-being-a-criminal life, not "bending over for the establishment"; they don't need anonymity and payment-censorship resistance and have no problem if their service provider complies with the law, so if the main advantage for some means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency is simply avoiding these regulations, then that provides no added value (and possibly negative value i.e. risk) to them, and they would reasonably not choose that. There could be all kinds of non-banklike decentralized means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency, but there's some self-segmentation - if some seller would be obeying AML, KYC and IRS cash reporting regulations, then they might as well be banklike, since they'll be competing with banklike institutions, and if not, then yeah, that's a crime and would naturally be attacked by governments and avoided by a large portion of honest citizens. There are certain niche markets for whom it's important to be beyond the reach of the law, but that's not a need for most people, for most people even a decentralized solution would have to obey all the relevant KYC and other laws if they'd be comfortable in using it. A professional buyer/seller on localbitcoin is very much comparable to a smaller version of Coinbase with less reputation and thus needs to offer some advantage so people would pick them instead of Coinbase, and I'm struggling to see what that advantage would be other than evasion of regulations. It's clear that decentralization can help with that, but can it help with something else, something that a law-abiding consumer cares about? One can argue about the details of regulation and licencing, but even if they would be relaxed to facilitate operation of small decentralized players, in any case the "above board" market will have to ensure that KYC (anti-anonymity), AML (filtering) and tax reporting for any large volumes, that is not negotiable; and the "underground" market that avoids that won't be attractive to most customers because of the risks involved by, as you say, governments attacking it and jailing operators.