5 ms·
The Physics and Physicality of Extreme Juggling
- sarreph 9y agoTangent, but just wanted to thank you, Colin, for piquing my interest in Maths at a talk you held when I was at school. It was maybe a decade ago now, but putting 2 and 2 together and seeing you on HN is a very surreal thing indeed!
- ColinWright 9y agoVery kind - thank you. Feel free to email me to get/be/stay in touch, and to let me know what you're doing.
- nightcracker 9y agoI loved your appearance on Numberphile :)
- ColinWright 9y agoWow - thank you! That video should get to 200K views by the end of the year - fingers crossed. Not as many as other Numberphile videos, but pretty good. It was disappointing that it got basically zero reaction here on HN, but <fx: shrug /> I might submit it again ... it has been eight months.
- weinzierl 9y agoI find it a bit amusing that the headline uses the term "Extreme Juggling". Not because it's too clickbaity, but I think the juggling community should have invented that name. "I'm going to an extreme juggling event." sounds much better than the dull "numbers juggling". On the other hand it wouldn't have done much to make numbers juggling more popular. If we are honest it is a quite disappointing subject to anyone outside the juggling community. Ask some random person what they believe about how many objects an average juggler can keep in air and you will get answers from 10 to 20. The reality looks more like this [1]: Balls People 3 200M 4 5M 5 500K 6 50K 7 10K 8 1K 9 200 10 40 11 10 12 2 And these numbers are for throwing and catching just once. The hard reality of every juggler is just: Do a few simple three ball tricks and people will get excited, show them your five ball routine they will fall asleep. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/juggling/comments/2mfurs/how_many_people_in_the_world_can_do_five_balls/ https://www.reddit.com/r/juggling/comments/2mfurs/how_many_p... (3 years old and the top numbers obsoleted by the OP)
- ColinWright 9y ago> The hard reality of every juggler is just: Do a few simple three ball tricks and people will get excited, show them your five ball routine they will fall asleep. There is a significant difference between demonstrating a skill, and being entertaining. The best street acts I've seen have been largely trivial with regards the skill level, but phenomenally entertaining because of the way the act was constructed. Numbers juggling is a skill that has effectively zero entertainment value for the non-initiated. And yet people always ask ask many one can juggle, and if you say "N" they then follow up with "Can you juggle N+1?" I'm always baffled by that, because if you actually do, they really don't care. The take-away? People are weird, and entertainment beats skill any day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dasil003 9y agoI'm a little surprised the fall off from 3-4 is four times more than 4-5. After half a year of practice I could sustain a 4-fountain. A couple decades later I think I've still never hit more than 20 catches on a 5-cascade. But I guess if we're talking about flashing 3, that's a pretty low bar.
- taeric 9y agoThe rhythm for juggling 3 is fairly straight forward for me. I confess I have not looked at what the equivalent for 4 would be. It seems clearly different in a way that practicing 3 doesn't help get to 4.
- ColinWright 9y agoFour is genuinely different, but there are now many, many exercises you can do with three which once mastered that makes four almost trivial once mastered. The same is true with going from four to five, etc.
- mhh__ 9y agoExtreme juggling makes me think of https://youtu.be/hFP4C0PQ4jU https://youtu.be/hFP4C0PQ4jU
- dahart 9y agoThere’s an interesting surprise: the Shannon Juggling Theory. > By building on the juggling theory of Claude Shannon (yes, that Claude Shannon—the father of information theory was also an avid juggler), Kalvan's studies detail the ways that juggling more balls requires a simultaneous increase in the height, frequency, and precision of one's throws.
- agumonkey 9y agoI guess he saw vertical space as channel capacity
- dahart 9y agoLOL, but I bet you’re right! I was just thinking about the relationship between gravity, and throwing & catching juggling balls vs. the weight of the balls. The apex height & number of balls determines the juggling frequency. Or, a frequency & number of balls determines the height. Fix any two, the third falls out. Some important constraints are that holding a weight in your hand reduces your acceleration, and that at a fixed juggling frequency, doubling the number of balls requires a 4x increase in the apex height. (Shannon might say that channel capacity is proportional to the square root of apex height at a given juggling frequency). In the video, Kalvan measures Barron shaking his arms twice as fast (without holding any weight), but appears to jump to the conclusion that it means he might be able to juggle twice as many balls. They speculate that accuracy might be the reason that Barron doesn’t achieve his physical potential. But since the weight of the balls slows down the max juggling frequency, and since adding more balls means throwing quadratically higher, Barron could be right, that it may require more strength than he has.
- foreigner 9y agoPro tip: if you do a juggling trick and then your audience asks "How many was that?" You should always add at least two to the actual number.
- jacquesm 9y agoNo thread about juggling should be without a link to Anthony Gatto's story: http://grantland.com/features/anthony-gatto-juggling-cirque-du-soleil-jason-fagone/ http://grantland.com/features/anthony-gatto-juggling-cirque-...
- jpatokal 9y agoPreviously discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7671214 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7671214