3 ms·
>> What cats do? How cats respond to things? How they interact physically with their environment? That’s all statistically learnable. Not at all. At least not
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> What cats do? How cats respond to things? How they interact physically with their environment? That’s all statistically learnable.
Not at all. At least not in practice and certainly not for any significant subset of the things that "cats do" or the ways they "respond to things".
You can certainly collect some examples of all the behaviours you describe above, but there are so many of them you are never going to have enough to model a cat's behaviour with anything like significant accuracy.
- red75prime 9y agoDGANs learn to generate realistic faces. Do you think it's impossible, because there are so many different faces?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThe generation is limited to features very close to the ones seen by the network in examples - i.e., to a limited domain. Here is an explanation of the limited ability of deep networks to generalise beyond their dataset, by Francois Cholet (maintainer of Keras): https://blog.keras.io/the-limitations-of-deep-learning.html https://blog.keras.io/the-limitations-of-deep-learning.html
- red75prime 9y ago(Shrug) NNs are universal function approximators. A critique of existing approaches is important, but it will not last.
- ben_w 9y ago> never going to have enough “Hey Siri show me cat videos” “Here are some videos I found of ‘cat’ on the web:” «Link to YouTube page saying “About 79,900,000 results”»
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoThe parent discusses: >> What cats do? How cats respond to things? How they interact physically with their environment? Not "how does a cat look on youtube".
- ben_w 9y agoYou’re the second person who’s tried to correct my interpretation of my own posts this week. What’s that quote about losing grandparents? :) Anyhow, my point was that there is plenty of data about the sort of cat behaviour which humans collectively find notable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI see what you mean- you're saying that you can find 79mil cat videos on youtube, so you have 79 million examples of cat behaviours. That might sound like a lot - but it's still not nearly enough to model a cat's behaviour. To convince yourself that this is the case, subtract 79 million from infinity. The number remaining is the number of cat behaviours that a model trained on 79 million youtube videos would never have seen and therefore not know how to deal with. See, the point is not how much data you have- it's how much data you're missing. If the amount of data you have is a tiny part of the whole, then you can't model the whole very well. It's already hard enough to train an image classifier to recognise still images (video frames) of cats. You're proposing to train some kind of model (it wouldn't be a classifier anymore) to recognise -and reason about- not only the likeness of a cat, but the relation of a cat with its environment; with arbitrary environments and arbitrary entities in those environments. And the cat is interacting with those arbitrary entities in the arbitrary environments in arbitrary ways. Seriously, you're looking at an extravagantly large number that nothing we have right now can handle. What is the quote about grandfathers? ~.^
- ben_w 9y ago