6 ms·
The success of Coinbase seems to indicate that customers are voting with their wallets that "No Banks" and "Decentralization" (including anonymity and censorshi
by PeterisP 9y ago
The success of Coinbase seems to indicate that customers are voting with their wallets that "No Banks" and "Decentralization" (including anonymity and censorship resistance) are not actually that highly desirable features for most people, they're willing to give them up and eager to use a trustworthy centralized service that's a bit more convenient and handles the technical risks for them.
- tmh88j 9y agoDo you think decentralization is not actually that desirable, or that there are just very limited avenues for buying/selling? Cryptocurrencies are scary enough for most people, throwing them into a forex like platform on currencies they don't understand the technology behind only amplifies the confusion and reluctance. I think the desire for decentralization is very real, but the "front end" technology hasn't caught up yet.
- PeterisP 9y agoI think that decentralization as such is not an "end goal" for pretty much everyone. Decentralization is one of ways that can enable some particular features (e.g. untraceability or censorship resistance) that can be valuable but the value of these features is different highly situational and can be low or even negative for many people; so it could be more constructive to talk about the benefits those particular features and not centralization in general. E.g. in my opinion most people don't want irrevocable untraceable transactions from their account as that increases fraud risk and (in their particular case) doesn't bring much benefit. Some do benefit from that, but it's a minority in the general population (but a large portion of early cryptocurrency adopters). Most people actually want something like a credit card payment that has a clear benefactor and the ability to recall the payment in case of fraud or other dispute. In other cases, the value is so low people are not willing to "pay" even very low price of convenience to gain them. There are some people (and locations!) where there is large motivation to avoid various capital controls and possibility of government control, but for most people in first world countries it's preferable to have their money in the reach of local legal system rather than outside, as they'd expect (and need!) the legal system to protect them in case of disputes and have a low risk of it working against them. Of course there are all kinds of exceptions where people might desire a way to get undeclared money (say, to avoid making child support payments) but that's usually a sufficiently large motivation only if you want to defraud someone and most people actually are honest and pay what they're due. Also, there are all kinds of trivial reasons why you'd want an institution to handle the trade - e.g. if you're investing, you'd need proper documentation for the crypto purchase so that it'd be tax deductible for the crypto sale, otherwise the whole sale could be treated as taxable income.
- tmh88j 9y agoDecentralization doesn't have to mean anonymization. The real benefits lay in the lack of a middle man to take a cut and possibly slow down processing times.
- Marazan 9y agoDecentralisation increases the number of middle men! Unless you are talking g pure peer to peer with no discovery service.
- colordrops 9y agoNot really. Pure peer to peer is always an option with truly decentralized systems, so you can always completely bypass the middle man. It's not really decentralized if it's not "pure" peer to peer.
- Marazan 8y agoBitcoin with only you and one other person is pretty useless. It's entire utility is predicated on a entire network of middlemen doing the mining.
- colordrops 8y agoJust because there are different roles on the network doesn't make it centralized. Furthermore you can set up a mining node yourself.
- Marazan 8y agoWhich adds a middleman! I think there is some serious misunderstanding of the relationship of middlemen and centralisation here.
- PeterisP 9y agoGiven the current Bitcoin processing fees and time, a decent centralized middleman could plausibly offer off-chain bulk transactions within their "network" that are faster and cheaper, and only periodically settle the totals on-chain.
- simias 9y ago>I think the desire for decentralization is very real Ideology aside, as a random human being, why would I care about that? I need to buy bread at the bakery, I can use cash, my "centralized" Visa or my Bitcoin wallet, all other things being equal what difference does decentralization make? And if it's solely about principles then I have bad news. I think most people would agree that ideologically speaking if you value privacy it makes more sense to use Duckduckgo rather than Google search, yet even though DDG now offers a quality of service comparable to the big G it still remains extremely confidential. The friction to get from one service to the other is like 3 clicks in your browser's UI, yet most people don't care. If 99% of people can't be bothered to ditch Google search in favor of something else even though there's very little friction, how can you ever hope to convince people to switch from Visa to a bitcoin wallet which is significantly less convenient and makes it easy to irrevocably lose your money? That's a pipe dream IMO.
- Fnoord 8y agoWhat is interesting is some kind of way to measure in percentages why people use cryptocurrencies. Speculation? Privacy reasons? Security reasons? Ideological reasons? Careless about environment?
- CamTin 8y agoMy sense is that it's mainly speculative, with a strong base of "honest" demand from people with security concerns (ransomware, drugs, money laundering, other crime) that preclude them from using the regular banking system. This is all on top of the initial users, Usenet-style "cryptoanarchists" who actually got the whole network running in the first place, but who are now a tiny minority of actual users, though perhaps a majority of the people who have already made a fortune on this stuff, and thus are now leading investment in the space. In a way, these are just speculators who bought early for reasons other than money (like for example, that it seemed like a cool conceit from a William Gibson novel).
- erikpukinskis 8y agoWhat about maybe technically illegal money moving not otherwise tied to criminal enterprise? The model example for me was someone in the U.S. sending money to their grandmother in Iran. Although perhaps that’s become legal again now.
- DSingularity 9y agoWell, I think you are going too far with your claim. Nobody is giving these properties up, you can withdraw your coins. If Coinbase said “we won’t allow withdrawing coins” and customers kept using CB then you can make the claim you are making.
- PeterisP 8y agoThey're not giving these properties up permanently, but they're choosing not to use them. Just as people using banks instead of cash implies that they feel that the advantages of banks outweigh the disadvantages, the fact that people choose not to withdraw (and fully control) their coins but instead "bank" them with coinbase is some indication that decentralization isn't an important issue for them and that they're not going to take advantage of its benefits whatever those may be.
- Nuzzerino 8y agoThe "Decentralization" vision hasn't really been fully realized, and when it is working, it's not necessarily talked about or noticeable. Whether it's desired or not has no bearing on a service's popularity. Many do not desire the centralization of data collection yet still use Facebook and Google because it provides shortcuts. Point being, more users on Coinbase doesn't imply that decentralization is not a desirable feature (and IMO it's not a product feature at all but rather an architectural one that users aren't really deciding for or against).
- PeterisP 8y ago"Many do not desire the centralization of data collection yet still use Facebook and Google because it provides shortcuts." is evidence that they don't have a significant desire for decentralization, their actions indicate that it's just a weak nice-to-have wish compared to their actual desires (e.g. getting these shortcuts), that it's not something that matters enough to actually base their decisions on it. It's the purest form of expressed preference - if people systematically give up A to gain B, then it's clear that they actually don't desire A that much and that they actually do desire B, no matter what they might say. The same applies to Coinbase - all this implies that for many, many users decentralization is not a feature that's desirable enough to matter, that it's benefits are not noticable and not important enough to make it a serious factor in making their decisions; whatever "the decentralization vision" is, it's not relevant enough so that they'd be willing to give up other benefits to gain these of decentralization.
- mijamo 8y agoThat is just wrong. It would d be true if and only if user had a perfect information anf comprehension,and if cost is equivalent.
- PeterisP 8y agoWhy do you think that the cost has to be equivalent? The difference of cost would be a perfect measure of the strength of that desire; if people would be willing to pay a significant premium to get X, then that's a credible sign that they desire X and it matters to them; and if they're not willing to pay a nontrivial premium to get X then clearly it's not valuable to them. The qualifier about perfect information and comprehension is legit, but given that, if you'd choose decentralization only if the cost and other circumstances are equivalent then that's a sign that decentralization is worth zero.
- dustingetz 8y agoThe trust is still decentralized unless coinbase someday drops external blockchain interop, i have a hard time imagining exactly how that could come to pass
- superkuh 8y ago> they're willing to give them up Sure. But why are alternatives so scarce or difficult? Because federal and state governments are going out of their way to attack any non-banklike means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency. From heavy regulation (see: New York) to arbitrary abuse of unrelated regulation in form of police action (localbitcoin sellers atttacked and jailed under KYC). This funnels people into players that are willing to bend over for the establishment like Coinbase.
- PeterisP 8y agoYou have a really good point there, the situation is not really indicative of a free choice to give up anonymity but rather of a somewhat forced choice between a 'law-abiding' service versus an 'outlaw' service model that has less restrictions but gets harassed by the authorities. However, for the majority of people, obeying local laws (including AML/KYC regulations) is simply a part of their normal not-being-a-criminal life, not "bending over for the establishment"; they don't need anonymity and payment-censorship resistance and have no problem if their service provider complies with the law, so if the main advantage for some means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency is simply avoiding these regulations, then that provides no added value (and possibly negative value i.e. risk) to them, and they would reasonably not choose that. There could be all kinds of non-banklike decentralized means of converting fiat to cryptocurrency, but there's some self-segmentation - if some seller would be obeying AML, KYC and IRS cash reporting regulations, then they might as well be banklike, since they'll be competing with banklike institutions, and if not, then yeah, that's a crime and would naturally be attacked by governments and avoided by a large portion of honest citizens. There are certain niche markets for whom it's important to be beyond the reach of the law, but that's not a need for most people, for most people even a decentralized solution would have to obey all the relevant KYC and other laws if they'd be comfortable in using it. A professional buyer/seller on localbitcoin is very much comparable to a smaller version of Coinbase with less reputation and thus needs to offer some advantage so people would pick them instead of Coinbase, and I'm struggling to see what that advantage would be other than evasion of regulations. It's clear that decentralization can help with that, but can it help with something else, something that a law-abiding consumer cares about? One can argue about the details of regulation and licencing, but even if they would be relaxed to facilitate operation of small decentralized players, in any case the "above board" market will have to ensure that KYC (anti-anonymity), AML (filtering) and tax reporting for any large volumes, that is not negotiable; and the "underground" market that avoids that won't be attractive to most customers because of the risks involved by, as you say, governments attacking it and jailing operators.
- ataturk 8y agoThat sounds good, but I get the distinct impression that most crypto holders don't understand tech very well at all, nor what the true risks are. Furthermore, these places like coinbase, aren't they just bankers who moved into the crypto realm? If it were possible to avoid banks altogether, for sound money to exist, and for governments to subsequently be less all-powerful, I'd be all for crypto. However, I don't believe in fairy tales.
- itsthejb 8y agoAs someone who recently tried to help a friend with recovering a lost/forgotten/who knows DashCore wallet password, containing a reasonable decent amount of funds, I'm skeptical that _most people_ will be willing to accept sole responsibility for their financial security. Most would rather defer to a third party. Which rather undermines the entire crypto project, it would seem