5 ms·
This is an amazing visualization, but I don't like using the term "bloat." What would you take away? Keep in mind that Chrome's architecture is purposefully app
by scott_s 16y ago
This is an amazing visualization, but I don't like using the term "bloat." What would you take away? Keep in mind that Chrome's architecture is purposefully approaching that of an operating system.
- blasdel 16y agoPlease stop repeating that canard, it got old years ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=297297 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=297297
- argsv 16y agothis is a bit newer http://www.chromium.org/chromium-os http://www.chromium.org/chromium-os
- blasdel 16y agoI'm actually waiting to buy a Netbook until it comes out, in the vain hope that someone will ship a decent ARM-based system using it. But it is just slightly-extended Chrome running directly in X unparented without the standard Gnome Desktop BS on otherwise stock Ubuntu.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agotmux+vim+chrome is all i really need. (and a full posix system down below, of course)
- blasdel 16y agoWhat I want is NaCL implementations of urxvt+SSH and VNC/RDP. I don't need yet another local posix system to maintain, I want remote access to my real server where my main screen session lives, and I want that access to live in a tab.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agoyou can get vnc over html5, thought it may not be as fast as you'd like.
- scott_s 16y agoI thought that analysis was ridiculous the first time I read it. I read Chrome's design docs when they were released. Chrome's design is approaching that of an operating system. Considering that it has to manage processes, there is no alternative.
- blasdel 16y agoBut that's the thing, it's only managing processes, not scheduling them nor managing the minutia of their stacks — it devolves that responsibility to the real kernel by using 'dumb' native processes instead of inventing its own fucked coroutines with a browser-wide GIL for all the logically-independent javascript environments. It is less OS-like than any other major browser!
- scott_s 16y agoCorrect, it is not an operating system. Just as the Java Virtual Machine is not an operating system. But when you start using principles and common designs from operating systems, you are approaching the design of an operating system.
- mcbain 16y agoThat chunk of "third_party" stuff is a pretty tempting target. Instead of using shared libs - like those that you've probably got on your system already - Google appear to like slurping everything into the one blob to solve dependency/versioning issues.
- _delirium 16y agoIt's probably not a terrible default, given their cross-platform development. Slurping everything into your app bundle is the official way of doing it on OS X anyway, and more or less the only sane way of doing it on Windows, whose DLL-versioning is notoriously bad. So if they were doing any factoring out of shared libraries, it'd be solely for the Linux version, which I could see them not considering worth the hassle.
- cperciva 16y agoThat chunk of "third_party" stuff is a pretty tempting target. Not all of it. Part of the third_party code is a modified version of bsdiff, and as the bsdiff author I specifically endorse the shipping of modified versions of bsdiff with the software which required the modifications.
- WalterGR 16y agoI don't like using the term "bloat." It's an extremely non-specific term that people use to describe software they don't care for, much as people cast arguments they don't like as "FUD". I was in a conversation with someone who said he felt IE 9 was bloated. I asked him why. "The right-click context menu is too big." "Uses too much RAM", "requires too much disk space", and "has too many dependencies" can all be valid complaints. But it seems that in most uses, "bloat" = "has one or more features I don't use."
- othermaciej 16y agoHaving too many features is valid usability complaint. In fact, it probably harms the user quite a bit more than "requires too much disk space".
- palish 16y agoIn practice, not really. People just ignore what they don't use.
- Lerc 16y agoThey also don't use what they can't fathom. A plethora of options can make it difficult for a new user to find the features they want. Yes they do ignore the unwanted features, but they also ignore features they would use if they knew about them. In that respect the notion of bloatedness is even amplified because a larger portion of the software is provided but idle.
- jmtulloss 16y agoWhy do you believe this?
- othermaciej 16y agoIn practice, yes really. Simplicity is one of the basic principles of good Human Interface design. User testing bears out that users find it hard to do even basic tasks with a more complicated program. Now, sometimes it is possible to add features in a way that is unobtrusive enough that it doesn't affect usability for basic tasks. But it's a tough design challenge to do this, not a given. By the way, I think Chrome overall does a pretty good job of design simplicity. But the "just ignore the features you don't want" argument is not a good basis for HI design.
- billiob 16y agoIt's useless to have N versions of the same library on your system. I prefer that my favorite distro takes care of updating one particular library if there is a security bug than having to wait for google to take care about it. It's what is done in gentoo: http://phajdan-jr.blogspot.com/2010/08/www-clientchromium-now-uses-system.html http://phajdan-jr.blogspot.com/2010/08/www-clientchromium-no... Currently, it uses the system libraries for: • bzip2, • codesighs, • cros, • icu, • jemalloc, • lcov, • libevent, • libjpeg, • libpng, • libxml, • libxslt, • lzma_sdk, • molokocacao, • ocmock, • pyftpdlib, • simplejson, • tlslite. As TODO, there is still zlib due to an issue during compilation. It would also be great to have V8 as a different project so that it could be used outside of chrome with much less pain.
- est 16y agoor type about:credits in your chromium address bar
- bnoordhuis 16y ago> It would also be great to have V8 as a different project so that it could be used outside of chrome with much less pain. http://code.google.com/p/v8/source/browse/trunk/ http://code.google.com/p/v8/source/browse/trunk/ ?
- asmosoinio 16y agoThe term "bloat" is not used anywhere else than in the URL.
- gjm11 16y agoAnd it looks to me as if the only reason it's even in the URL is that that's the name of the tool he wrote to extract and display the information.