3 ms·

They mention that they kept asking her for different forms of ID and then a clearer picture. Here's a scenario that's consistent with what they've said: She s

They mention that they kept asking her for different forms of ID and then a clearer picture. Here's a scenario that's consistent with what they've said: She shoots a porn in an AirBnB rented by someone else. At some point the host pulls up some porn and recognizes his house. He reports this to AirBnB. AirBnB looks at the porn, suspends the account of the person who rented it, and then tries to figure out who the performers are. They get the real names of the performers, and then search their system for people with that name. "Jay" matches the search, but they want to make sure it's the same person as in the porn, so they ask for a clearer picture. After they're confident that she is the person who filmed a porn in an AirBnB without the permission of the host, and they discover that she's also listed on an escort site, they suspend her account. If this is what happened, and I think it's pretty likely, AirBnB did exactly the right thing.

forkLding 8y ago
Quote from article: "I’ve never shot porn in any Airbnbs in my name, and I didn’t have any complaints" - Sara Jay. The report and Sara Jay say they have never done a porn shooting in an AirBnB, although this could be a he-say she-say scenario, because will need an investigation. But shouldn't have immediately stopped the account before notifying the actual Airbnb user and then proceeding with an investigation.
- xbmcuser 8y ago
  She did say any Airbnb in my name. The qualifier means she did at an Airbnb which someone else booked. Otherwise she would have said I never shot any vidio in an Airbnb rental the need for a qualifier makes it suspicious.
  - wang_li 8y ago
    Or it means she knows she’s never rented a place via Airbnb for the purposes of porn production, but can’t say one way or the other about each and every location she has worked at. Do you think that Robert Downey Jr. knows the contract details of every location for every movie he’s ever worked on?
chrismcb 8y ago
In your scenario, how is air bnb doing the right thing? She doesn't have a contract(nor a terms and condition) with airbnb. But you think it is OK to suspends here account because someone else broke the rules?
- cameldrv 8y ago
  Suppose Led Zeppelin rolls into a hotel room and trashes it, as they frequently did. Will the hotel chain just ban the band's manager because he was the one who booked the room? Presumably they don't want any of 'em back. What Jay is saying is: "I promise that whenever I go to someone's home who thinks we're a quiet couple on a weekend getaway, but really we're bringing a camera crew, and your house is now going to be on PornHub, I will do it under a different account. Please let me use this account normally." AirBnB is saying that if you lie to your hosts and shoot a porno at their house, you're banned. Simple, obvious.
notacoward 8y ago
> If this is what happened If. That's one way it could have happened. There are several others, all less reassuring than that. In light of what we know about privacy practices throughout the industry, and about Airbnb's practices in particular, I don't see how your optimism is justified.

forkLding 8y ago

Quote from article: "I’ve never shot porn in any Airbnbs in my name, and I didn’t have any complaints" - Sara Jay. The report and Sara Jay say they have never done a porn shooting in an AirBnB, although this could be a he-say she-say scenario, because will need an investigation. But shouldn't have immediately stopped the account before notifying the actual Airbnb user and then proceeding with an investigation.

xbmcuser 8y ago
She did say any Airbnb in my name. The qualifier means she did at an Airbnb which someone else booked. Otherwise she would have said I never shot any vidio in an Airbnb rental the need for a qualifier makes it suspicious.
- wang_li 8y ago
  Or it means she knows she’s never rented a place via Airbnb for the purposes of porn production, but can’t say one way or the other about each and every location she has worked at. Do you think that Robert Downey Jr. knows the contract details of every location for every movie he’s ever worked on?

chrismcb 8y ago

In your scenario, how is air bnb doing the right thing? She doesn't have a contract(nor a terms and condition) with airbnb. But you think it is OK to suspends here account because someone else broke the rules?

cameldrv 8y ago
Suppose Led Zeppelin rolls into a hotel room and trashes it, as they frequently did. Will the hotel chain just ban the band's manager because he was the one who booked the room? Presumably they don't want any of 'em back. What Jay is saying is: "I promise that whenever I go to someone's home who thinks we're a quiet couple on a weekend getaway, but really we're bringing a camera crew, and your house is now going to be on PornHub, I will do it under a different account. Please let me use this account normally." AirBnB is saying that if you lie to your hosts and shoot a porno at their house, you're banned. Simple, obvious.

notacoward 8y ago

> If this is what happened If. That's one way it could have happened. There are several others, all less reassuring than that. In light of what we know about privacy practices throughout the industry, and about Airbnb's practices in particular, I don't see how your optimism is justified.