4 ms·
Which was it - virus-guided evolution or cryofrozen eggs? That piece is all over the map. And it begs the question: why is alien life DNA-based at all? Without
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Which was it - virus-guided evolution or cryofrozen eggs? That piece is all over the map.
And it begs the question: why is alien life DNA-based at all? Without addressing that, its just a comedy piece.
- sulam 9y agoWithout trying to support the piece, the DNA question has a rich history of being explainable via the panspermia theory.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoOk, then the point of the piece, that the Octopus is special in being 'alien', becomes moot? Everything is 'alien'.
- Nomentatus 9y agoBut in this case, the leap in complexity is so obvious we can tell it's alien (they say.)
- jonny_eh 9y agoThat argument sounds awfully similar to that of Intelligent Design. I imagine that Punctuated Equilibrium is a far simpler explanation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium
- Nomentatus 9y agoIf you find a watch on a beach... was the old argument. The argument in the paper is that the Octopi change is so fast and so immense it leaves every known instance of PE, including human evolution, far behind along with every other known leap forward. I'm not endorsing that view, just retailing it.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoI'm wondering if the fossil record supports the conclusion that octopuses actually got all the claimed features at once? How does a fossil (of a soft creature, notoriously rare to fossilize at all) indicate the presence of color change, large eye and so on. Or is it a DNA argument. Then I'm back to why DNA at all unless everything is alien. In which case, why the article. Its like "there's this one alien guy in Idaho..." instead of "There's other intelligent life in the universe!!!"
- Nomentatus 9y agoGood point, re soft bodies fossilizing more rarely - because what may have happened is the squids just didn't show up in the fossil record for a very long time, nor the proto-squids. Ocean acidification at various periods (say due to CO2 variations at different periods, which were large) would be a factor. I'm not saying the 33 scientists weren't well aware of these considerations, though.
- foo101 9y agoI think JoeAltmaier (your parent commenter) still has a point. If the leap in complexity of octopuses is so obvious that we can tell it's an alien, do you mean other earlier life in our planet was not alien? That would not make sense because it would be hard to imagine that two independent evolutions of life led to the same protein-based, DNA-based life. So the only reasonable theory is that both the earlier life in our planet as well as octopuses are aliens which is JoeAltmaier's point.
- Nomentatus 9y agoThe 33 scientists do not mean that. I think, in fact, to make their argument go forward, you pretty much have to assume that squid arrived earlier from a different branch of the same alien lineage, but were quickly - so quickly - followed by vasty more complex octopi, that we know that octopi didn't evolve here. The authors aren't anti-panspermists. JoeAltmaier's wasn't the one introducing the idea of panspermia. His point was, instead: "why even write this paper focusing on octopi if all life is alien" and my answer was, 'cause this is the one time you can really prove that (according to the authors.)
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoBut it also then supports the much larger issue of Panspermia. That should have been the title/main point then? Yes this is quite a strange article.
- Insanity 9y agoIn the paper they mention both (paper was linked in the article): > In our considered view the totality of the multifactorial data and critical analyses assembled by Fred Hoyle, Chandra Wickramasinghe and their many colleagues leads to the bare minimum yet plausible scientific conclusion – that life was seeded here on Earth by life-bearing comets as soon as conditions on Earth allowed it to flourish (at or just before 4.1 Billion years ago); and living organisms such as space-resistant and space-hardy bacteria, viruses, more complex eukaryotic cells and organisms (e.g. Tardigrades), perhaps even fertilised ova and plant seeds, may have been continuously delivered ever since to Earth helping to drive further the progress of terrestrial biological evolution. EDIT: Further in the paper they talk specifically about the octopus in more detail: > Thus the possibility that cryopreserved Squid and/or Octopus eggs, arrived in icy bolides several hundred million years ago should not be discounted (below) as that would be a parsimonious cosmic explanation for the Octopus' sudden emergence on Earth ca. 270 million years ago. Full disclosure: I'm a software engineer not a biologist, so the next bit is my interpretation that could be wrong: As I get it from the paper they seem to suggest that octopi came into being either due to genes inserted into a terrestrial ancestor whereby the genes came from space. OR by the landing of extraterrestrial eggs on our planet.