7 ms·
Interesting. But it also feels like this helps to return the body to a more natural state. The question then becomes: What in modern living is knocking the body
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
Interesting. But it also feels like this helps to return the body to a more natural state. The question then becomes: What in modern living is knocking the body off its center? How could the need for this "cure" be prevented?
Any thoughts?
- aviv 9y agoAcids and large protein consumption. Meat, wheat, dairy. Toxic to the human body. It's really quite simple. You eat death, you get death.
- perfmode 9y agoPlants are death too no?
- aviv 9y agoIf you think a melon or celery represent death more than a piece of steak sliced out of a dirty, diseased cow full of nasty man made food, hormones and "medications".. then you are quite far gone. Hopefully you will see the light before the illnesses kick in for you.
- a_t48 9y agoI hope you remember to sanitize your keyboard daily. :)
- aviv 9y agoI'm not sure I understand your point - are you comparing the cleanliness of my keyboard to the horrible living conditions of a typical cow? I highly doubt the keys on my keyboard have manure on them.
- matte_black 9y agoYou’d be surprised. If you’ve ever taken a dump and then returned to your keyboard right after without taking a shower then fecal matter has almost certainly found its way to your keyboard. Fecal flakes proliferate through the air when you take a shit. The stronger the smell, the more flakes there are. They stick to your body and clothes, and then inevitably smeared on your keyboard.
- nate_meurer 9y agoExcellent. Multiply by 10 if you have dogs.
- aviv 9y agoIn an effort to make a smart witty comment you completely missed my point. I said my keyboard doesn't have manure on it, not any kind of fecal matter.
- a_t48 9y agoFor that matter - you don’t keep your toothbrush in your bathroom do you?
- jrace 9y agoHave you stopped to think about what "feeds" the plants and vegetables? There is a whole lot of "death" in the dirt.
- robbiep 9y agoNone of us are getting out alive. Sprouting pseudo science isn’t going to keep you here any longer
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aviv 9y agoAlso, don't forget to drive without a seatbelt, never get any exercise, don't brush your teeth, and don't have a fire extinguisher. Because, you know, anyway none of us are getting out alive.
- nso95 9y agoExcept exercise and seatbelts aren’t pseudoscience
- throwaway5752 9y agoWith all due respect, there is science on plant based diets and caloric restriction being correlated with increased longevity. Vegans still die, non-vegans can still outlive them, anyone can get hit by a bus, etc.
- toasterlovin 9y agoLet’s just get this out there: there is no long term randomized controlled trial that has ever been conducted which is capable of proving that one diet is better than other diets. Period. Nutrition science is a joke. It’s basically all short term studies which tell you nothing about long term effects of diet, or it’s long term epidemiological studies which are fundamentally incapable of controlling for confounding variables.
- DenisM 9y agoI heard it that the Mediterranean diet is the most studied of them all, and it seems [1] that all studies are within 5 years of length. So yeah. No long-term studies. It's not even clear if we have hope for such. The military could summon the discipline, but soldiers do retire early. Maybe the officers, I don't know. [1] https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/5-studies-on-the-mediterranean-diet https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/5-studies-on-the-medite...
- coldtea 9y ago>Acids and large protein consumption. Meat, wheat, dairy. Toxic to the human body. It's really quite simple. You eat death, you get death. Whereas vegans don't die? Also "toxic to the human body" is just bad dietary advice.
- aviv 9y agoFast food vegans sure do die. And if you believe that nothing you can eat can be toxic to your body, you already lost in life.
- jrace 9y agoAll vegans die, all things can be toxic to the human body, water and even air. Plants and vegetables were "alive" in some capacity before they were torn from their natural habit, violently macerated and forced into a highly acidic stomach to be digested over a period of hours.
- aviv 9y agoFruits are given to you by nature, no one takes them violently (unless picked unripe, which is a problem on its own in this country). Also unlike dead flesh, they take at most 30ish minutes to digest, not hours where they go rancid in your body like most other foods.
- coldtea 9y ago>Fruits are given to you by nature, no one takes them violently You'd be surprised: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic >Also unlike dead flesh This has a tone of religious indignation in it. You do know that it's not only perfectly natural, but that there are species that have evolved evolutionary to eat meat, the ones we call carnivores, right?
- aviv 9y agoAgain you resort to extremes to justify your (likely) unhealthy lifestyle and make a point that really contributes nothing to the conversation. And then, what is your second point there? Are you a carnivore? Why is "dead flesh" triggering you so much? Are you ripping into live animals in the wild and swallowing them whole? I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt, I would love to meet the first lion using HN.
- PerfectElement 9y agoThere are many good rational arguments in favor of veganism. "You eat death, you get death" is not one of them.
- shorttime 9y agoAcids? Like stronger acids than the stomach acid already inside of the human body? I doubt that considering stomach acid damages teeth. Nobody would have teeth left. Large protein consumption? Like what many many people do for health reasons, keto, body builders, etc? People in prime health condition? And what about fructose malabsorption with certain fruits and vegatables? Some people can't eat certain things otherwise it will make them sick due to this illness. Go back to reddit with your pseudo science trolling. HN is one of the few decent spots on the internet for discussions and it certainly isn't improved by people like you.
- toasterlovin 9y agoNot sure if you’re aware of this, but dairy has been a fundamental part of European diets for thousands of years. Plenty of Europeans live to old age.
- robbiep 9y agoYour question needs re framing. The cell, and life by extension/function, is a reverse entropy machine. Is must be continually off centre in order to be able to go on generating its functions, such as enabling you to ask questions based on feelings
- VectorLock 9y ago>The cell, and life by extension/function, is a reverse entropy machine. I've always thought the same thing myself. Posits some interesting mind experiments on the possibility of the big crunch vs. heat death of the universe.
- 49bc 9y agoI think about this sometimes when on a ketogenic diet. You shed 3 or 4 lbs of water in the first few days. Then it’s an effort to make sure I keep enough salt in my diet.
- ropeadopepope 9y agoAnd magnesium, I hope.
- ropeadopepope 9y ago> What in modern living is knocking the body off its center? Abundance and industrial processing. Europe doesn't have the same problem the rest of the 1st world has with obesity. They also have crazy strict food purity laws. No additives. Very little processing. What you get is what's on the label[0]. I don't think it's a coincidence that people see improvements in their health once they start eating "closer to the farm." We're also a victim of our own success in many ways. The human body is still adapted to operate under pre-agricultural conditions. Food consumption was more along the lines of "binge and starve" than "steady grazing". Our bodies deteriorate quickly in space when we no longer have Earth's gravity to fight against. Is it really a surprise that our bodies also deteriorate when we no longer have hunger to fight against? [0]: Before anybody says that what's on the label is accurate in the US, look into what 'natural flavor' means. There's nothing natural about them and they aren't necessarily flavorings.
- okr 9y agoI would like to see a definition, of what "a center" is. And what is normal? Is pre-agriculture normal? Or were they all sick, just in a different way? Is getting a hundred years old normal? Is being healthy on the surface normal or just a temporary balance between all chaotic influences? Or is it just luck, to be able to cope with present environment? I do not know. And i can not judge, if we have enough data to judge. But i think, calling out abundance and industrial processing, i am sure, there are correlations, but as reason for knocking people off center? Its just energy, no?
- ryanmarsh 9y agoIf you look at where our gut originated from (requiring cooked food incidentally some think around the time fire was discovered/tamed) then “normal” would be starve/binge. The agricultural revolution would be a very recent development. Hell we have an unnecessary organ just for binging on fat.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoIf taking baking soda helps then not having to take baking soda would be normal. The arc of my point / question was is this: Why do we keep "curing" that which can be prevented? Instead we keep grabbing the balloon, and then pay (more) to add that "cure" to our lives. T2 Diabetes is not normal. It is preventable. We have a "cure." But instead of using that cure, we're investing - read: wasting - resources looking for a cure that will need to be paid for. Inflamation is (likely) the same. Mind you, baking soda is inexpensive. But as cures go, prevention (and a return to a natural norm) is #1.
- wolco 9y agoUnhealthy oils promoted as healthy or plain fry food will change the ph in your digestive track.
- DenisM 9y agoMy pet theory is "refined sugar and other simple carbs'. Simple carbs spike up blood sugar through the roof, the body responds by dumping insulin, the insulin causes blood sugar to be sequestered in fat and muscle cells (as intended), but if the dump is large it may overshoot and the blood sugar falls through the floor. Aka "sugar crash". The crash will of course make you crave food again, the same simple carb kind. Vicious cycle. This sort of see-saw messes you up real bad. So I was told [1] [1] https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259 https://www.amazon.com/Why-We-Get-Fat-About/dp/0307474259
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI agree with you. These things, esp refined sugar, are an historic abnormality. But we assume that since it's in the supermarket and on TV (e.g., soda) it's perfectly fine. It's not. It's normalized. So normalized that suggesting otherwise make you the crazy one.
- erdewit 9y agoThe problem could be over-breathing, i.e. exhaling too much CO2. This lowers the blood CO2/bicarbonate levels and inhibits the oxygen release from hemoglobine (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_effect). The remedy is to breath less, both less frequent and less voluminous. Very little breathing is needed to saturate the blood O2 levels, as can be checked with a simple pulse oxymeter. Also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buteyko_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buteyko_method