4 ms·
There's problems with that attitude. First, it offers no scientific insight. We don't learn anything about the fundamental nature and skeleton of minds by simpl
by Barrin92 9y ago
There's problems with that attitude. First, it offers no scientific insight. We don't learn anything about the fundamental nature and skeleton of minds by simply replicating evolutionary processes. It does not grant us knowledge.
The equivalent in engineering would be to throw over trees and rocks in the hope of building a bridge. Clearly, that is unsatisfactory, we strive to understand the meaning of systems so that we can reason about them and alter them in predictable and fundamental ways.
Secondly, we don't know how likely it is that evolution produces intelligence. Maybe we're the only intelligent spot in the universe and it's an aberration. It took 4 billion years as well.
That seems to be a fundamentally impoverished way to go about things. We shouldn't forego the ability to understand minds at a deep level just because we have made practical strides in closed domains. That would be to mistake a trojan horse for an actual horse.
- gerbilly 9y ago>The equivalent in engineering would be to throw over trees and rocks in the hope of building a bridge. Imagine if aliens dropped a machine learning computer on earth in the 17th century. Maybe we'd have never bothered to derive the laws of classical mechanics.
- taeric 9y agoI don't follow. Classical mechanics are still very useful, no?
- gerbilly 9y agoYes, but we might have never created metal models and theories if we had a magical machine that could predict the outcomes of physical systems. The machines might have replaced classical mechanics, but the downside is that the machine would be a black box, and we would never really understood how it derived its results.
- taeric 9y agoFair. That assumes we wouldn't try and understand the black box. I suspect somebody would have, but I have nothing to base that suspicion.