4 ms·
So I suppose the "anyone can edit" tagline is a crock of shit? If an organization is publishing some info about me, it sounds like a giant pain in the butt if
by netsharc 9y ago
So I suppose the "anyone can edit" tagline is a crock of shit?
If an organization is publishing some info about me, it sounds like a giant pain in the butt if I have to learn their bureaucracy to get e.g. false information changed. At least have an ombudsman who could represent my grievances, if you built such a site. But nooooo, it seems because anyone can join and be involved in the mud-wrestle, that's what they have to do to be heard!
I wonder if politicians/celebrity can GDPR (to use that term as a verb) Wikipedia to delete all info the site has about them. After learning about this 5 minutes ago, I'm outraged! (Do note, this sentence is tongue-in-cheek!)
- tptacek 9y agoYou obviously can edit. And it's especially easy if you're the subject of an article to correct false information about yourself; see WP:BLP. What you're not promised is the ability to win any given debate between yourself and other editors. What would you expect? How could the project possibly work otherwise?
- Retric 9y agoNo, you can't edit, even simple spelling mistakes get reverted regularly. It's designed to be an overly byzantine bureaucracy to discourage edits so a relatively small group can maintain control. Remember if 100 million people made meaningful contributions daily there would be no way to maintain that control. Arguably that works well, but it's almost meaningless to call it a wiki.
- tptacek 9y agoOne of the indisputably nice things about WP is that there's a record of everything that happens. Can you cite an example where a simple spelling mistake was reverted, so that the page right now is running the incorrect spelling of something?
- Retric 9y agoThat's not what I am saying. I am saying that if you look at Wikipedia history you can find plenty of places where an anonymous user/occasional editor fixes a spelling mistake that was then reverted. That history sticks around far longer than anyone one version. And for that user all they see is that their effort is pointless. "if you make an edit which is good-faith reverted, do not simply reinstate your edit – leave the status quo up" ... "propose your reverted change on the article's talk page or pursue other dispute resolution alternatives." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reverting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reverting I am not saying the policy is unreasonable, but it combined with the interface does discourage people. As to an improvement, if Wikipedia sees the same edit applied twice it could detect this and walk someone through the policy.
- nullymcnull 9y ago> I am saying that if you look at Wikipedia history you can find plenty of places where an anonymous user/occasional editor fixes a spelling mistake that was then reverted. You're essentially refuting yourself by making the same claim again, and yet still without offering a single example of something you are claiming is rampant. If there are "plenty" of examples, it should be easy to link a few. I'm skeptical, because I've made many small, always anonymous edits over the years, mostly correcting spelling mistakes and bad grammar. Most of these edits were even made from dynamic IPs - and yet none of them were reverted.
- Retric 9y agoBy the nature of Wikipedia it really depends on how many people / editors are looking at the page. But, feel free to dig through the reverts they are really common and not just for regional variations in spellings. PS: I realize listing even 50 in all of Wikipedia is not nessisarily meaningful so no I am not going to waste my time tilting at windmills.
- teddyh 9y agoYou have made an assertion that a certain thing is a common occurence on Wikipedia, and have multiple times been asked for sources. The fact that you are still refusing to provide any sources (all the while claiming it is “really common”) is clear grounds for dismissing your point out of hand.
- k1m 9y agoOne of Cross' targets attempted to edit his page and his changes were quickly reverted by Cross due to conflict of interest. What it seems you're suggesting here is that those unfairly targeted on Wikipedia, as Cross is doing, should learn the labyrinthine processes Wikipedia expects to correct their entries. And then presumably to put in the same amount of time Cross is putting in (hours and hours on weekdays and weekends) to monitor their pages for more abuses from him. Should we not be more concerned about blocking those who are clearly in the wrong here?
- tptacek 9y agoWhich BLP page are you referring to here? I don't see it in the article we're talking about. (I believe you, I just don't know what you're talking about). I don't know what "clearly in the wrong" means. Cross and I don't share a POV; from the little I know about him (exclusively: this article) I find his politics noxious. But I would be extremely disturbed if my opinion about his politics somehow controlled Wikipedia.
- k1m 9y agoSee: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Piers_Robinson&type=revision&diff=840417662&oldid=840090450 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Piers_Robinson&ty... and https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Piers_Robinson&type=revision&diff=840418411&oldid=840417662 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Piers_Robinson&ty... I'm not suggesting anyone base the block on their opinion of his politics, but of his behaviour on Wikipedia. There's clearly a conflict of interest when someone who is openly hostile toward someone else and taunts them on Twitter, then goes and makes the kind of edits he's making to their Wikipedia page. There's of course a bigger issue of how Wikipedia deals with this problem more broadly. But the fact that they're unwilling to act on a single editor whose actions have been exposed doesn't inspire much confidence.
- belorn 9y agosaying that "anyone can edit wikipedia" is identical to saying that anyone can contribute to the linux kernel. Its both true and false depending on how you look at it. Yes, anyone can send in a patch. No, only a very small subset of the world population has the knowledge and experience to create a patch that gets accepted. Yes, they do want more contributors and want to encourage all users to contribute. No, they can not accept all patches.
- pvg 9y agoThat's not what 'identical' means. Although this thing isn't even similar, never mind identical.
- omeid2 9y agoThat is not a fair comparison. Linux patches generally gets accepted based on technical merit, some politics aside; But it seems like most Wikipedia contributions are subject to the inside political considerations and bureaucracy.
- tony101 9y agoWikipedia contributions are generally subject to sourcing requirements (i.e. information must be backed by reliable secondary sources), not "political considerations." Wikipedia cares about verifiability, not truth itself. See this example that illustrates the policy using the flat earth theory[1]: > "Wikipedia is not worried per se about whether the theory that the Earth is flat is true. There must be current, reliable and independent sources substantiating claims that the Earth is flat. But there are no such sources that are current (almost no scientists have thought the Earth was flat since about the fourth century BC), that are reliable (reliable sources are reviewed for accuracy), or independent (a journal published by a Flat Earth Society would not be independent.)" > "If Wikipedia had been available around the sixth century BC, it would have reported the view that the Earth is flat as a fact without qualification. It would have also reported the views of Eratosthenes (who correctly determined the Earth's circumference in 240 BC) either as controversial or a fringe view. Similarly if available in Galileo's time, it would have reported the view that the Sun goes round the Earth as a fact, and if Galileo had been a Vicipaedia editor, his view would have been rejected as "originale investigationis". Of course, if there is a popularly held or notable view that the Earth is flat, Wikipedia reports this view. But it does not report it as true. It reports only on what its adherents believe, the history of the view, and its notable or prominent adherents. Wikipedia is inherently a non-innovative reference work: it stifles creativity and free thought, which is a Good Thing." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Why_Wikipedia_cannot_claim_the_earth_is_not_flat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Why_Wikipedia_cannot...
- obelix_ 9y agoHoly God are you living in a dream state. We have presidents getting elected on false info. Wars being faught on false info. Biz empires and fortunes built on false info. Celebrity and product worship produced on false info. But you want to believe that getting false info changed is simple? How can you believe that in 2018?