22 ms·
So it ensures that unequal outcomes are always the result of random chance, and never the result of a skill gap. That seems exactly backwards: you would want eg
by closeparen 9y ago
So it ensures that unequal outcomes are always the result of random chance, and never the result of a skill gap. That seems exactly backwards: you would want egalitarian policy to minimize random factors like your parents’ wealth so that factors like the student’s own skills dominate. Can anyone elaborate?
- throwaway2048 9y agoIts much more likely to be a result of a "parental wealth gap", because its those who are going to pay consultants lots of money (and likely conspire with other wealthy people to rig the system) to ensure optimal placement.
- Avshalom 9y agoThe particular skills considered necessary to succeed in a meritocratic society tend to get defined post hoc.
- Barrin92 9y agothe ability of a student to strategize is strongly correlated to the education and wealth of the parents. (as pointed out in the post). the discrepancy in strategic aptitude is itself a result of chance. Only through this absolute form of randomness, you are actually eliminating the wealth, education and aptitude bonus of upper-class households. Your comment is a nice signifier of the difference in American and Dutch culture. Dutch people don't buy the idea that individual strategizing is going to advantage the interests of lower-class students, because they recognise that lower class students are already disadvantaged when they enter the system.
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoGenerally speaking, we're not trying to reduce random factors. We're trying to reduce hereditary factors. There are already plenty of intrinsic hereditary factors (intelligence, appearance, health). We want to limit the ability of extrinsic hereditary factors (wealth, connections) to influence egalitarian processes, and in some cases even correct for them.