2 ms·
The intuition that lotteries are substantially more fair than markets is a strange one. There are already lotteries that redistribute money. If we accept that r
by closeparen 9y ago
The intuition that lotteries are substantially more fair than markets is a strange one. There are already lotteries that redistribute money. If we accept that random windfalls are the right way to allocate resources, why is it preferably to hand out million-dollar discounts on condos or school slots that confer millions-dollar lifetime earning bumps vs. simply writing million dollar checks? The check winner has strictly more options than the condo owner, who is deed-restricted on resale, or the school slot winner, who might prefer to retire early instead.
Lotteries get around unequal capability to spend, but so does the right tax policy or even an alternate currency scheme where you get non-tradable points to allocate across the various socialized axes of life. In a system with several independent lotteries, it’s possible to lose all of them, win the ones you don’t care about and lose the ones you do, or win them all. Allocating money gets you a kind of conservation effect: maybe you don’t care about school, so you got a nice house instead. Maybe the opposite. But with roughly the same spending capacity as everyone else, you definitely won’t win or lose big on all axes at once, and can make tradeoffs to win when it’s more important to you.