4 ms·
I think it's that Americans distrust elites who purport to make decisions on their behalf. American are not objectivist hyperindividualists, they are social cr
by dnautics 9y ago
I think it's that Americans distrust elites who purport to make decisions on their behalf. American are not objectivist hyperindividualists, they are social creatures that thrive on the narrative of the greater good (the superhero movie is a rather American genre). But American history is littered with questionable judgements of the elites - tuskeegee syphilis experiments, internment of Japanese Americans, various middle East interventions, bailouts post 2008 crash, Vietnam war... Etc.
The American "way" traditionally is that social justice is an individual responsibility. You can see this residually in traditional volunteer fire departments and social clubs like knights and rotary which used to be mutual benefit clubs, providing for members in the event of sickness etc.
- jorams 9y agoI don't understand your argument. When GP says "local students always accept that the rich get to set them.", they are saying US students accepted the fact that the rich got to set the rules. That seems, to me, the opposite of "distrusting elites". It also seemed to be used in favor of Trump: "he's a successful businessman, so he must be fit to lead the country." Maybe our definition of "elites" is different? To me Americans seem to distrust the government, while trusting rich people much more.
- majormajor 9y agoI think you're misunderstanding his usage of "on their behalf." I think the poster means a distrust of claims that a decision is for the third-party's good. The rich setting the rules is transparently favor of the rich. And you're expected to also optimize for yourself. This might be accepted by some more easily than rules set "for the greater good" if one is particularly cynical about such claims.
- fallingfrog 8y agoA lot of that might be down to an extremely well funded marketing/persuasion campaign.. there is an aspect of genuine belief too though, no denying it.
- ardit33 9y ago"the superhero movie is a rather American genre" . - Lol Sure, where did Zeus, Promethues, Thor, and countless of other 'gods/titans/demi-gods' heroes come from? Almost all, either European and non European countries have their Mythological beings, (either gods, super human heros, etc...). The US is just good at creating commercial versions of them and putting them in film, the but concept of 'an hero' is as old as humanity itself.
- _vertigo 9y agoI think you'll find "an hero" means something different entirely from "a hero"
- nine_k 9y agoI suppose that the popularity of the superhero genre in comic books started with Superman, then continued with Captain America, and other indigenous characters. Characters of the Norse pantheon is a much-much later addition.
- nemothekid 9y ago>Sure, where did Zeus, Promethues, Thor, and countless of other 'gods/titans/demi-gods' heroes come from? That's odd that you would outright deny American culture influence on stories like Thor. Not to mention the countless other Superhero movies which are strictly American. Next,the value we place on our superheroes reflect American culture. I'd be hard pressed to call the classical Greek stories of Zeus or Prometheus "superheroes". Zeus wasn't exactly an upstanding role model.
- dnautics 9y agoZeus was practically an anti-hero, and iirc there are arguments that ancient Greek culture treated them as such by way of using them as cautionary tales .
- dnautics 9y agoNo claim was ever made that the superhero archetype was exclusively American. I used the word "rather" carefully.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoBut isn't "The rich get to set the rules" exactly the elites making decisions for everyone?