2 ms·
> I can recommend this paper [0] that talks about simulations that show a black hole just implodes in a weird way and kind of does not stop imploding, due to sp
by pdonis 9y ago
> I can recommend this paper [0] that talks about simulations that show a black hole just implodes in a weird way and kind of does not stop imploding, due to space-time getting stretched with a speed above that of light, as measured within a frozen moment in time, and summed over some line from inside to outside
I would not put too much credence in this paper. First, it seems to be contradicting the well-known singularity theorems proven in the late 1960s and early 1970s, and that doesn't give me very high confidence in its results. Second, just reading section 1 of the paper I'm seeing what look like obvious misunderstandings of the simple collapsing dust model; for example, this:
"Consider the case of a particular set of initial data or conspiring alien civilization that seeks
to extract mass from this infalling cloud by moving much larger and denser bodies near it so
that some of the particles leave the collection and follow and, possibly, join the larger mass. The
aliens have infinite time to pursue this project..."
This is wrong: the aliens do not have infinite time to extract mass from the collapsing cloud. The fact that light signals emitted outward by the cloud will continue arriving at the aliens' ship, far away, indefinitely (in practice how long will depend on how low frequency radiation they can detect) does not mean that the aliens can continue going down to the cloud, getting material from it, and bringing it back up indefinitely. In fact it's simple to show (and is a common textbook problem in GR) that, if we call the time by the aliens' clock at which the collapse starts t = 0, there is a finite time t > 0 after which even a light signal emitted by the aliens towards the cloud will not reach the cloud until after it has collapsed beneath an event horizon and formed a black hole. (And for a black hole of mass a few times that of the Sun, this time is not very long: for example, if the hole has 10 times the Sun's mass and is collapsing from a starting radius of a billion kilometers, which is about 100 million times the horizon radius for that mass, the time t is about a million seconds, or about 12 days.)
In other words, the paper is making a simple mistake: it's treating processes going inward towards the collapsing cloud, as though they worked the same as processes coming outward from the cloud. But the two are not the same, because of the asymmetry of the cloud's gravity: it pulls things inward. And when I see a paper making this kind of simple mistake in the beginning, my credence in the rest of what it says goes way down.