25 ms·
Majority of those surveyed who are connected to the Chicago School. Literally the classically liberal school of thought of Friedman. So, we'd probably have to
by monocasa 9y ago
Majority of those surveyed who are connected to the Chicago School. Literally the classically liberal school of thought of Friedman. So, we'd probably have to check if they're OK if they said anything else.
Also, I have issues with the whole premise of the question, as net neutrality isn't really about "for the right to send that traffic using faster or higher quality service". There's no magic go faster lane that they want to turn on, but can't because of regulations. It's about not allowing the ISPs to slow down other traffic.
- throwaway37585 9y ago> Majority of those surveyed who are connected to the Chicago School. How so? The majority of those surveyed are not from Chicago. According to the About section: > ...our panel was chosen to include distinguished experts with a keen interest in public policy from the main areas of economics, to be geographically diverse, and to include older and younger scholars. As with the IGM’s US panel, the experts are all outstanding researchers in their fields. The panel includes recipients of top national and international prizes in economics, fellows of the Econometric society and the European Economic Association, members of distinguished national and international policymaking bodies in Europe, recipients of significant grants for economic research, highly accomplished affiliates and program directors of the Centre for Economic Policy Research and the National Bureau of Economic Research, and past and current editors of leading academic journals in the profession. > It's about not allowing the ISPs to slow down other traffic. What you think a policy “is about” and its actual consequences are very different things.
- monocasa 9y ago> How so? From the About section: Chicago school is a broad term for an economics ideology, like "Austrian". Those surveyed are part of that ideology. > What you think a policy “is about” and its actual consequences are two very different things. So tell me then, how does this magical go faster lane work from a technical perspective, and how is net neutrality not letting them turn it on? Please be specific.
- throwaway37585 9y ago> Chicago school is a broad term for an economics ideology, like "Austrian". I know. > Those surveyed are part of that ideology. I’ll repeat my question: How so? > So tell me then, how does this magical go faster lane work from a technical perspective, and how is net neutrality not letting them turn it on? Please be specific. I don’t know what “magical” lane you’re referring to, since I don’t believe in magic. Are you trying to score rhetorical points by using such language? Does it make you feel better to attack strawmen?
- monocasa 9y ago> How so? It's literally the point of the organization that did the survey; these economists are members of this organization. > I don’t know what “magical” lane you’re referring to, since I don’t believe in magic. Are you trying to score rhetorical points by using such language? Does it make you feel better to attack strawmen? You're the one being intentionally vague with "what you think a policy 'is about' and its actual consequences are very different things." I'm trying to get you to be specific concerning the technical details of your argument, but you seem to be fighting that pretty hard.
- throwaway37585 9y ago> It's literally the point of the organization that did the survey What is “the point” of the organization that did the survey? > these economists are members of this organization. In the sense that they are surveyed by this organization? Do you mean that anyone who is surveyed by organization X belongs to X? > You’re the one being intentionally vague with "what you think a policy 'is about' and its actual consequences are very different things." I wasn’t being vague, much less intentionally. I was merely pointing out that what you (or I) think a policy “is about” is very different from its real-world consequences. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unintended_consequences > I'm trying to get you to be specific concerning the technical details of your argument What “argument” of mine are you referring to? And why do you hold me to such high standards of “technical details”, which you don’t seem to apply to yourself? That’s just plain hypocrisy. > but you seem to be fighting that pretty hard. I honestly have no idea where you’re trying to go with this.
- AmIFirstToThink 9y agoAs a consumer, I am precisely buying the right to download from those content providers as fast as possible using my speed tier (10 Mbps or 1 Gbps). I am paying the ISP to get that data. When I ship a package, post office doesn't get to charge the recipient of the package after charging the sender for the shipment? Why would a Internet user buy ISP service if the users can't get the content from other users on the internet, be it content providers or other end users i.e. peer-to-peer? I pay $70 for internet service precisely because I can watch youtube/netflix over my internet connection. ISPs asking youtube/netflix to pay on top of that is ridiculous. It is actually the ISPs who should be sharing revenue with content providers. Without that content, nobody will buy that high-bandwidth internet connection at high price point. Netflix charges $11 per month for their service. Comcast charges $70 per month for their service. It is Comcast who should be paying the content providers that their customers use the most. How many people got internet connection so that they can watch Netflix and YouTube? If Netflix and YouTube stopped serving customers of an ISP, how many would stay with that ISP? Would Comcast's services be in such demand if there was no services like Netflix or YouTube? It is not that Netflix and YouTube are making Comcast spend more, but without Netflix and YouTube nobody will buy Comcast's high tier connections. Everybody will just use $15 10Mbps connection.