2 ms·
Ah, I see. This is a definition other than the one I understood, which is most assuredly less precise than the one understood by people who have extensively stu
by jerf 9y ago
Ah, I see. This is a definition other than the one I understood, which is most assuredly less precise than the one understood by people who have extensively studied analysis. (This being the internet, let me be very clear that I'm basically saying my definition was wrong.)
(I'm pretty decent in mathematics in the general sense, reasoning from axioms, proofs, etc. But as I came up on the computer science side, I'm very lopsided into discrete mathematics, which is a bit unusual. Almost every other way to become a good mathematician makes you lopsided into real analysis and the fields that build on that.)
- jordigh 9y agoThere's a certain cultural thing in mathematics that is kind of hard to convey unless you've been around other mathematicians about what is a definition and what constitutes proof. And these things definitely change culturally with time. Our current standards of analysis are quite modern. From a modern viewpoint, nobody really bothered to define continuity and limits until the 19th century, even though calculus is from the 17 century. The 19th century cultural fixes had a purpose: actual misunderstandings and/or errors crept up in previously published works. So when we get pedantic about what things and use early 20th century formalism, we do so kind of as a reaction to historical misunderstandings. When we ask, "what is the derivative of f at 0?", we're trying to show holes in understanding that have been patched by more modern frameworks.