5 ms·
On complexity vs sophistication: During the cold war, a US company noticed the USSR had stolen the plans for a natural gas pipeline system, but not the softwar
by hedora 9y ago
On complexity vs sophistication: During the cold war, a US company noticed the USSR had stolen the plans for a natural gas pipeline system, but not the software.
In response, the US introduced an integer overflow bug that was uptime dependent, and took something like 6 months to hit. The bug simultaneously cranked up the pumps and closed all the valves in the network.
It was known that the Soviet economy would crash in under a year without the ability to cheaply move natural gas, so they couldn’t test long enough to find this.
A year or so later, the DoD’s seismographs detected the largest non-nuclear explosion in human history.
The main impact wasn’t the explosion or the short-term economic damage. The main impact was that the USSR stopped trusting stolen software, which set them way further back, economically and militarily.
Arguably, that ~one line of code was infinitely more sophisticated than stuxnet.
- jespern 9y agoDo you have a source for this? I can only find reports from "At the Abyss", which are uncorroborated.
- gregw2 9y agosomewhat described in the book Victory, by Peter Schweizer
- burger_moon 9y agoWow I have never heard this story before! I had to look it up, for anyone else interested here's a quick wiki about it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberian_pipeline_sabotage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberian_pipeline_sabotage
- Lionsion 9y ago> On complexity vs sophistication: During the cold war, a US company noticed the USSR had stolen the plans for a natural gas pipeline system, but not the software. I think this account might be a bit wrong. The one I read said that the CIA acquired a "shopping list" of Western technology that the USSR wanted to acquire. It included the pipeline control software, so they arranged for a trojaned version to become available to the Soviet shoppers. Apparently this was a pretty common Soviet activity. Their electronics technology was behind the West's, in general. IIRC, many US semiconductor designs has little cartoons on the dies to taunt the Soviet reverse engineers.
- jocro 9y agoDo you have a link to more info? Would love to read more but can't seem to find anything.
- howox 9y agoHow do you even define sophistication in context of computer software? Let me try by defining the opposite. What would be unsophisticated computer program? I would say it is brute force algorithm. It is unsophisticated because it uses simple logic and iterative approach to achieve aim in inefficient manner. So sophisticated program is:concise(non-iterative), efficient (doesnt use too many steps to arrive at destination) and uses non-simplistic modeling of given problem. Anyone has anything better :)?
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoThis didn’t actually happen, but it makes a good story that is often repeated. http://jeffreycarr.blogspot.com/2012/06/myth-of-cia-and-trans-siberian-pipeline.html http://jeffreycarr.blogspot.com/2012/06/myth-of-cia-and-tran... Also, this story seems to be taking on a life of its own. You have some details that were not in previous rounds. Integer overflow based on uptime was not in the original unverified story.