3 ms·
Yes and there's nothing saying I won't be arrested and thrown into a cell for the rest of my life if I say something incorrect by mistake when entering the US.
by raverbashing 9y ago
Yes and there's nothing saying I won't be arrested and thrown into a cell for the rest of my life if I say something incorrect by mistake when entering the US.
There's nothing that says IRS won't prosecute you if someone buys you a soda and you don't declare it as income.
Or that you won't be prosecuted by someone in the US if your blog has a copyrighted image and you don't receive a DMCA request that was sent to you.
See how ridiculous that sounds?
All fines can be administratively and judicially appealed.
- downandout 9y agoYes and there's nothing saying I won't be arrested and thrown into a cell for the rest of my life if I say something incorrect by mistake when entering the US. That simply isn't true. That would probably be considered lying to a federal agent. There are strict federal sentencing guidelines that spell out exactly what the sentence should be based on several factors . This is how civilized laws work - you don't simply say "max is $20 million, good luck everybody!"
- raverbashing 9y agoYou're right, laws in Europe are uncivilized, maybe that's why they have the highest rate of incarceration in the world.
- downandout 9y agoGDPR is extremely uncivilized. Forgetting the absurd fines and burdens it places on companies for a moment, consider the extraterritorial reach that EU is claiming for itself. The EU has declared itself Grand Emperor of the Internet. Wars have been fought over less.
- barry-cotter 9y agoMany countries believe their law applies extraterritorially. The US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act applies to any company that does any business in the US. A German director of a Canadian company that pays a bribe to an Ethiopian government official can be prosecuted under the FCPA if they set foot in the US. Sweden will prosecute citizens, and I presume residents, who purchase the services of a sex worker abroad. I don’t believe Kim Dotcom ever set foot in the US before the New Zealand government arrested him on foot of a US extradition warrant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ethelward 9y agoOr, you know, just block European clients from your service if you don't agree to our laws? It's not like if the US laws didn't have any extraterritoriality.
- downandout 9y agoIt's not like if the US laws didn't have any extraterritoriality. This is a disingenuous argument. The US has never passed a law that is this easy to violate outside of its own borders, is this ripe for abuse, and carries such enormous penalties and burdens for essentially everyone in the world that wants to operate a website. In fact, no country has ever done this before. GDPR is different, and not in a good way.
- oblio 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_A... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd.
- donkeyd 9y ago> The US has never passed a law that is this easy to violate outside of its own borders The US has a law requiring US citizens living and working outside of the US to file taxes in the US. Not doing that is a crime. You'll probably argue that this is different, since it concerns American citizens, but it isn't different, because it's a US law that is very easy to violate outside of its borders.
- amaccuish 9y agoLol, the US has FATCA which makes it very difficult for fin-tech startups to work with americans. I'm an e-resident of Estonia, and almost all financial services state they cannot serve US clients.
- downandout 9y agoLol, the EU has GDPR which makes it very difficult for any startup to work with anyone because of the danger that someone from the EU might stumble by.
- DanBC 9y agoYou make it sound like US laws don't extend outside the US. Many of them do.
- oblio 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd. ? The guy committed an "US crime" in Russia, where what he did was not illegal. He arrived on US soil, where he committed no crime. He was still arrested and charged.
- downandout 9y agoThat’s one guy in one case (that was eventually dismissed). There are probably a few handfuls of other examples you can post here. It doesn't hold a candle to the millions of people and businesses liable under the GDPR who face a nasty framework of foreign laws with no limits on fines other than $10/20 million.
- oblio 9y agoGo read the law again. Read what the friendly people are answering in this whole sub-thread started by you.
- yls 9y agoNope. Read the law and check on how many countries have extraterritorial reach in their laws...
- fbelzile 9y agoI think you've got it backwards. GDPR is bringing civility back. I think it's great legislation that favors peoples privacy over business profits made by invading that privacy. As a business owner myself, I'm glad something like GDPR came along. I think it better reflects the society I want to live in.
- dwild 9y ago> I won't be arrested and thrown into a cell for the rest of my life if I say something incorrect by mistake when entering the US For the rest of your life? Source please? You can be put temporarily into a cell for plenty of stuff but that's temporary. A fine is pretty permanent and when it can be millions, well that's probably the end of your business too. > There's nothing that says IRS won't prosecute you if someone buys you a soda and you don't declare it as income. Isn't it simply paying back what you should have + interest? (with some threshold) Paying taxes is already part of the cost of running a business too (and that's a pretty low cost for a startup, versus having an actual trained DPO). > Or that you won't be prosecuted by someone in the US if your blog has a copyrighted image and you don't receive a DMCA request that was sent to you. Which is exactly why you try not to put copyrighted image over your website. Most of the times PII isn't something you can just avoid for a business. > All fines can be administratively and judicially appealed. Any appeal represents a cost. A cost that you can't always support until the end. At the end, it's all about the cost of the risk... that's it. GDPR seems a pretty high cost.
- ProblemFactory 9y agoThe IRS is probably the best US example of "proportionate punishments" and why people should not be overly afraid of GDPR. The tax laws are vastly more complex than GDPR. The maximum penalties for tax fraud seem to be $250,000 + cost of prosecution + 5 years in jail. If you make a small mistake on your taxes, and the IRS notices, you will probably receive a warning and have to repay it with interest. If you make a negligent mistake, you may be in addition be fined a small percentage, like 10-20%, of the amount you failed to declare. You have to conduct very large scale and intentional tax evasion for the maximum penalties to apply. The IRS could argue for and try to apply the maximum penalties for a lemonade stand, but they don't. And people go on with their lives, put in their best effort to comply, and can be confident that they will be treated fairly.
- 8note 9y agonothing requires you to be let out of those cells. All those people in Guantanamo are going to die there.