4 ms·
You're misunderstanding my post, so I'll try to put it another way. Suppose I tell you I have proof I created a perpetual motion machine. You'd probably laugh m
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
You're misunderstanding my post, so I'll try to put it another way. Suppose I tell you I have proof I created a perpetual motion machine. You'd probably laugh me off as a crank, or at least demand an extremely high level of evidence, to even listen to me.
The EMDrive breaks the known laws of physics as much as any potential perpetual motion machine would, so for it to be correct would imply as much is wrong as our knowledge of physics as the existence of a perpetual motion machine would.
- roywiggins 9y agoAnd indeed, you can build a perpetual motion machine out of a reactionless drive. "any device with a thrust-to-power ratio greater than the photon rocket would be able to operate as a perpetual motion machine" https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494 https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.00494
- Nomentatus 9y agoThe Casimir effect already produces perpetual motion (in that sense.) Which raises the specualtive question of whether the Emdrive exploits the Casimir effect to obtain a tiny thrust (in which case a drive subdivided into a vast number of really small trapesoidal sections might produce much more thrust.
- roywiggins 9y agoThere's a simple way to get free energy out of a working em-drive: "at some point, the kinetic energy of the device-driven mass exceeds the energy input, and if this energy is collected via decelerating the mass (via regenerative electromagnetic braking, for example), then there would be a net gain in energy." How do you get a net gain in energy out of the Casimir effect?
- Nomentatus 9y agoVibration is continuous. Free energy you can get - whether we'll ever harness it to obtain thrust or electric power I don't know - but endless minor amounts of heat, yes.
- roywiggins 9y agoHow do you produce vibration with a force that makes two metal plates stick together? Once they're stuck together, the force goes away. There's no repulsive Casimir effect, and insofar as they bounce, they will quickly come to rest. It's like trying to extract free energy by dropping a ball to the ground.
- v_lisivka 9y agoLet accept that there is Ether, and Ether is like water. In such case, Casimir effect may depend on the flow of Ether, so if plates are in free space and exposed to unbound Ether, then Casimir effect may happen when plates are oriented perpendicular to flow (as usual), and may NOT happen when plates are parallel to flow (my prediction).
- roywiggins 9y agoThe Casimir effect was both predicted by quantum field theory and observed to behave more or less exactly as predicted, so there's very little room for supposed etheric effects. If they were observable, we probably would have seen them just by accident already.
- v_lisivka 9y agoBut Ether Wind was disproved by Special Relativity theory, not by Quantum Theory. I see no conflict between Quantum theory and Ether theory. But, if you wish, let accept that there is Quantum Field, ...
- roywiggins 9y ago
- kmm 9y agoYou misunderstand the Casimir effect. It's a relativistic analogue of the van der Waals interaction, with a very curious alternative derivation from zero point energies. It is not free/negative energy, it is not free momentum, it was never a controversial subject, we only didn't have the practical means to measure it. Exploiting the Casimir effect can't give free momentum, because the derivation of the force is rooted in quantum field theory, which like any other physical theory of the last 400 years contains conservation of momentum at its very core.