3 ms·
Ask HN: Proton Mail or Gmail?
A friend of mine [no really] is ditching their cable ISP based account. They asked me about Proton Mail. My gut reaction was for most use cases it's not worth fooling with due to everyone's familiarity with Gmail and the higher blacklist potential for just about every other email domain.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoMost commercial email services are not going to get blacklisted: Staying off blacklists is their job. That concern largely only exists with "spin up your own mail" type concerns. I personally use FastMail, which is a paid provider that I highly recommend to people who value good email service. ProtonMail is really good for privacy, but there's challenges like the lack of normal IMAP support, that can frustrate the average user. I personally strongly recommend against giving an ad company your data, and could not recommend Google, but it depends on what your friend's values and concerns are. Note that regardless of the email provider they choose, they should consider buying their own domain and using it as an email alias, so they can easily switch email services later.
- mattkrea 9y ago+1 to FastMail. I hosted my own previously but I am incredibly happy with the decision. I've been with them for several years now.
- brudgers 9y agoThanks. Since I've pointed my friend to this thread. It's probably worth asking for a bit more detail what you mean by "good email service"...because that can mean different things to different people depending on use cases.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI've heard all too many stories about people get their Google accounts locked out, sometimes for unrelated events on other Google products/services, and having no recourse unless they happen to know a Google employee who can champion their cause internally: Google offers no customer support to Gmail users, and help forums are often of little use. IMHO, email is the most important service you have. Every other service you use is tied to it, and your email is more often than not the master key to your entire online identity. You'd be shocked how many other accounts you have that you may just not be able to recover if your email account disappears. One of the key things I get at FastMail is real, human support. I would strongly discourage entrusting your email account to anyone who doesn't have good customer service, and generally, that is something you do have to pay for. This is also why I feel owning your own domain and using it for your email address is so key: Even if I were to have an issue with FastMail, I could always redirect my email address to a different provider, and regain access to my services.
- inetsee 9y agoI have three email addresses. One Gmail for financial stuff (because Google Authenticator gives me easy 2 factor authentication) and two Yahoo addresses I've had for years (one for family and friends, and the other for everything else). Yahoo is changing their terms of service, and after trying to plow through pages and pages of legalese, I'm planning to drop Yahoo, and replace it with Proton Mail. I doubt if I really need the level of security Proton Mail provides, but I've just gotten tired of advertisers stalking me everywhere I go on the internet. Proton Mail may not be as easy or convenient as the other email providers, but I'd just like to get a little bit of my privacy back. [edit] spelling.