4 ms·
>... I frequent Europe and do not want to get into legal trouble on vacation. Does the author seriously believe this could happen? Enforcement of GDPR is simil
by pavlov 9y ago
>... I frequent Europe and do not want to get into legal trouble on vacation.
Does the author seriously believe this could happen? Enforcement of GDPR is similar to antitrust law. A regular police officer isn't going to fine you for that.
The author's anxiety makes as much sense as not traveling to the United States because you're worried that your one-person pottery business might be considered a monopoly under the Sherman Act.
- kybernetikos 9y agoBetOnSports, an AIM listed UK company took sports bets over the internet, including from US customers: > In July 2006, their then-CEO, David Carruthers, was arrested while changing planes in Texas on the way to Costa Rica from the U.K. In April 2009 he pleaded guilty to federal racketeering charges, and in January 2010 was sentenced to 33 months in prison.
- anonymouz 9y agoFrom Wikipedia: > BetonSports plc is a British online gambling company founded by Gary Kaplan in 1995. The company was one of the biggest players in the United States online gaming market, drawing in several billion US dollars in wagers in the early 2000s.[1] In June 2006 US authorities indicted the company and a number of its executives on RICO, mail fraud, and tax evasion charges arising from its supplying online betting to customers in the United States (the alleged crimes took place before the adoption of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006). This is about federal crimes committed by executives of a billion-dollar company. OP seems to be a solo open-source project, and violating the GDPR is not a criminal offense. This isn't even close to being comparable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kybernetikos 9y agoWhile I agree that violating the GDPR is much less likely to result in being pulled off a plane than running a company that allows people to gasp gamble on the internet, your characterisation of the problem as 'federal crimes' seems to suggest that there was something much more nefarious going on than simply allowing people in another jurisdiction to do something over the internet that is completely legal in the jurisdiction you are based in. I could be wrong, but according to my understanding, that's not the case. The 'federal crimes', were precisely enabling US customers to gamble over their phone lines. That was enough to get a publicly traded company in a friendly nation categorised as 'organised crime'. The other thing you mention about how it's not a criminal offense is something important a lot of people seem to be missing. If you're violating the GDPR and someone notices, the first thing that happens is that they work with you to try to correct the problem, not that they hit you with huge fines and laugh while twirling their mustaches.
- lovich 9y agoI don't like government, but companies sucking up everyone's data for sale right now certainly seem like mustache twirlers to me.
- anonymouz 9y agoMaybe we just misunderstood each other a bit: My point about the 'federal crime' is not to judge gambling as more nefarious, but to simply point out that the violated law in this case is a completely different type of law (criminal). As you correctly note, the GDPR is an EU regulation that will be enforced by national regulatory bodies through warning letters and fines. Unlike for criminal offenses, there simply is no way for it to be enforced by a police force or through arrests.
- stordoff 9y agoReading through the indictment, it appears that BetOnSports was actively (and repeatedly) advertising within the US. I feel there's a rather clear line between operating in one jurisdiction and merely accepting customers from overseas , vs. actively seeking out customers and doing business in a jurisdiction where your activities are illegal -- I'm not sure I would categorise it as "completely legal in the jurisdiction you are based in" when you are deliberately doing business, and spending money, in another jurisdiction.
- merinowool 9y agoAre you really can't imagine what state is capable of doing? Not so long ago they packed people on trains to gas them on an industrial scale, and there were people questioning whether this actually happened. Do you think jailing people for not complying with GDPR is not possible? Bookmark this comment and check in 5 years... if this site will even exist by then.
- jimnotgym 9y agoWell in the UK the only criminal offenses under gdpr are around falsifying records to fool the regulator or attempting to deanonymise data. Both of which are punishable by a fine, not prison. And since you can't go to prison for a civil offense I think your comment is misguided. Now if the state has got to the levels of your tasteless gas-chamber example, i don't think you need worry about data protection law
- merinowool 9y agoIf you don't pay a fine you go to prison...
- craigsmansion 9y ago> and there were people questioning whether this actually happened. Or equally bad: people trivialising it by comparing it to some new regulation to show how bad it is because "the state" somehow is involved.
- merinowool 9y agoI am not trivialising, just pointing out that state is capable of doing unimaginable things.