2 ms·
IANAAstronomer, but Quanta seems to be written for the general public. I'm not saying that any of the researchers have done anything wrong, merely that TFA need
by jessaustin 9y ago
IANAAstronomer, but Quanta seems to be written for the general public. I'm not saying that any of the researchers have done anything wrong, merely that TFA needs to do a little more work to support this prediction story.
- canjobear 9y agoYou seem to have an enormously strong prior in favor of conspiratorial fraud by astronomers...
- jessaustin 9y agoI could understand this response to my first post, since 'InclinedPlane had largely the same reaction. I had thought the post to which you've responded would have clarified the matter? Do you not believe me when I type "I'm not saying that any of the researchers have done anything wrong"?
- canjobear 9y agoConsider this as honest feedback on your writing: the way your first post is written heavily implies that something malicious and conspiratorial is going on, in such a way that is not defused by saying "I'm not saying something fishy is going on".