4 ms·
I appreciate the "great theory predicts new data" proposition, but the chronology seems off. In early 2016, two planetary scientists declared that a ghost plan
by jessaustin 9y ago
I appreciate the "great theory predicts new data" proposition, but the chronology seems off.
In early 2016, two planetary scientists declared that a ghost planet is hiding in the depths of the solar system, well beyond the orbit of Pluto.... Batygin and Brown made a case for Planet Nine’s existence based on the peculiar orbits of a handful of distant worlds known as Kuiper belt objects.
Later in TFA we learn:
The Dark Energy Survey first detected evidence for the new object in late 2014. Gerdes and his colleagues have spent the years since then tracking its orbit and trying to understand its origins.
So the data were "new" in 2014. I suppose the various grad students and lab assistants on Gerdes's team could all sign affidavits to the effect that they didn't directly or indirectly inform these two famous researchers in their field of this data, despite the fact that they routinely attend the same conferences and otherwise correspond about these exact issues. Still, it seems a bit sneaky for TFA to raise this point and not attempt to fill in this significant hole in the narrative.
- macintux 9y agoHaving the data on a hard drive or tape somewhere is not the same as someone looking at it or recognizing it for what it is. Heck, someone just looked at 20-year-old Voyager data to find evidence that it flew through plumes of water on Europa. The mind can only boggle at the sheer magnitude of cosmological data floating around the world right now.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThis is commonplace in astronomy, a lot of discoveries come about from analyzing old data. You are putting a bizarre tom clancy spin on this for no reason whatsoever.
- jessaustin 9y agoIANAAstronomer, but Quanta seems to be written for the general public. I'm not saying that any of the researchers have done anything wrong, merely that TFA needs to do a little more work to support this prediction story.
- canjobear 9y agoYou seem to have an enormously strong prior in favor of conspiratorial fraud by astronomers...
- jessaustin 9y agoI could understand this response to my first post, since 'InclinedPlane had largely the same reaction. I had thought the post to which you've responded would have clarified the matter? Do you not believe me when I type "I'm not saying that any of the researchers have done anything wrong"?
- canjobear 9y agoConsider this as honest feedback on your writing: the way your first post is written heavily implies that something malicious and conspiratorial is going on, in such a way that is not defused by saying "I'm not saying something fishy is going on".
- snowwrestler 9y agoIt happens in biology too, where scientists sometimes identify new species while examining old specimens that have been in museum collections for decades or longer.
- redial 9y agoI've had a book in my nightstand for at least 2 years and every once in a while I swear to myself "this month I'm gonna read it, this month..." then I fall asleep. I better call my layer and get my story straight for when the thought police get here demanding answers.