2 ms·
Unemployment Insurance suffers from over-protectionism due to "Protestant values". Because "work" is virtuous, not working is "sinful", so you must prove you ar
by WorldMaker 9y ago
Unemployment Insurance suffers from over-protectionism due to "Protestant values". Because "work" is virtuous, not working is "sinful", so you must prove you aren't entirely a sinner.
Despite the fact that every dollar you get back out of the Unemployment Insurance pool was most likely a dollar you put into the pool, people want to make sure you aren't just "wasting" resources.
If there is a better example for why the U in UBI needs to be truly Universal for it to really work, it's unemployment insurance. The more gatekeeping in a Basic Income scheme, the more likely it is to bring in human biases and human judgment calls. A lot of UBI complaints are the same "Protestant values" fights: "why should people do the godly thing and work themselves hard to death if you give them the basics for free?" Not everyone believes that work is godly, but yet we've commonly voted those that do in charge of what should be unbiased protection systems like Unemployment Insurance (and Social Security and Medicare, etc), and we've let them dominate the conversations.