2 ms·
Not sure if joking, but I agree, in a general sense. For skills above a certain level/specialization, I don't like the idea of a "full time, career teacher".
by SilasX 9y ago
Not sure if joking, but I agree, in a general sense. For skills above a certain level/specialization, I don't like the idea of a "full time, career teacher". In order to really ground the lessons/advice they're giving, they need to be a practicioner[1] too -- otherwise, your questions will get answered with "... that's what the book says" or some rationalization of some idiosyncratic ritual they favor. That doesn't impart a real understanding.
For a HS counselor, that would mean they also work as a career counselor outside to tell people whether or what jobs to change to, or to stay at their current one.
I wouldn't apply that to core education, as there are no e.g. professional adders, but you get the the picture.
I could go on, but that's a topic for another day, I guess.
[1] a retired or former practicioner would suffice here too
- gaius 9y agoI don't like the idea of a "full time, career teacher". This one - I still remember her name but I won't doxx her obv - I happen to know had gone from school to university to teacher training to my school. She had never been outside the education system in her entire life. But her job was to advise 16- and 18-year olds on how to set themselves up for career success... (I think she also taught Home Ec or some similar fluffy subject)