3 ms·
How far can we take this? Theft is a big deal for manufacturers. They spend good money on preventing it. But will they continue to spend good money on preven
by sandworm101 9y ago
How far can we take this? Theft is a big deal for manufacturers. They spend good money on preventing it. But will they continue to spend good money on prevention if instead they can just brick any lost devices? The nightmare is a manufacturer turning to a whitelist model, one where post-purchase the consumer must legitimize their purchase before use of the device. That DRM. There is massive overlap between the community of people who purchase SDR products and the group that will riot in the streets in protest of DRM.
Anyone who purchases tech devices owns some "pirate" content. When you buy a motherboard you don't know the pedigree of its hundreds of components. Trace each one and you will find a licensing or counterfeit issue somewhere. Should everyone be able to automagically brick counterfeit or stolen devices when those devices have been integrated, resold three times, and are now in the hands of innocent consumers? There are policy-based principals in western law that have long prevented such behavior in other arenas.
See: https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2/2-403 https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2/2-403
Not exactly on point, but an example of how we protect good-faith purchasers, even black-market purchase of "stolen" goods.
- gambiting 9y agoWhile I agree with you mostly, this is really a basic issue - devices stolen from the manufacturer are still owned by the manufacturer. They are, and should be, free to do with them however they please. It's a basic question of ownership and control over one's property in here.
- sandworm101 9y agoI'd have to know more about the "theft". I suspect that this wasn't a robbery in the dead of night. UCC § 2-403 states: When goods have been delivered under a transaction of purchase the purchaser has such power even though ... the delivery was procured through fraud punishable as larcenous under the criminal law. https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2/2-403 https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2/2-403 Basically, if an employee to other person who was "entrusted" with these goods by the manufacturer sells them, then innocent purchasers take full legal title. The good-faith purchaser is now the legal owner even if they purchased the goods from someone who wasn't a legal owner. The goods don not belong to the manufacturer. This is specifically to protect innocent people from debates between manufacturers and distributors, even where those distributors have stolen goods. The knock-on effect of this is that people who buy things in good faith from distributors don't have to worry about manufacturers (or police) raiding their homes ... which appears to be exactly what this manufacturer is doing by bricking these devices.
- eric-hu 9y agoSo does this mean the people who were fraudulently sold the Brooklyn bridge actually own it?
- icebraining 9y agoNo, because the fraudsters weren't entrusted with the bridge.
- sandworm101 9y agoNo. It has to be things that someone can clearly possess, something movable. The seller also has to be someone authorized to possess the thing and deals with such things regularly. The standard scenario: You take your guitar to a music store to be fixed. Some evil sale guy at the store instead deliberately sells your guitar. Your issue is now with the store. You cannot go after the guy who bought and is how holding "your" guitar. It isn't yours anymore. You have to sue the store for money and the store is free to try and buy the guitar back.
- gamblor956 9y agoWhat you're ignoring is that the guitar guy never had the ownership rights to your guitar, and thus could not give the ownership rights to the buyer. The UCC only allows the middleman bad actor to pass on the rights they actually had. The provision you quoted early merely contemplates that the middleman acquired ownership rights through deceptive means (i.e., fraud), which isn't the case here. The guitar guy acquired custodial rights, but not ownership. Thus, in pretty much every state in the US, you go to the police, and they take the guitar back, and the buyer has to go back to the store and get refunded. EDIT: The following provision is why the guitar guy never gets ownership. (From California's Commercial Code, but most states have made the same change to the UCC text in redefining what "entrusting" means): 3) “Entrusting” includes any delivery and any acquiescence in retention of possession for the purpose of sale, obtaining offers to purchase, locating a buyer, or the like; regardless of any condition expressed between the parties to the delivery or acquiescence and regardless of whether the procurement of the entrusting or the possessor's disposition of the goods have been such as to be larcenous under the criminal law.