3 ms·
> Now imagine a leaker inside your own brain. But it isn't like that at all. We don't judge people on their internal thoughts because they are fleeting and can
by godelski 9y ago
> Now imagine a leaker inside your own brain.
But it isn't like that at all. We don't judge people on their internal thoughts because they are fleeting and can even be random. But we do judge when someone distills those thoughts and starts opening their mouth or acting on them.
There was a well produced video and concept. This took quite some time. This was not a fleeting discussion just an interesting idea. This was distilled.
It isn't so much a leaker in your mind, but someone leaking what you gave a presentation on.
- EliRivers 9y agoWe don't judge people on their internal thoughts because they are fleeting and can even be random. I disagree. I think we don't judge people on their internal thoughts because we can't see those internal thoughts. If they became visible, people would start judging each other on them.
- wffurr 9y agoMotive is a relevant consideration in legal cases, in addition to speech and action. So no, we do in fact literally judge people in their internal thoughts.
- godelski 9y agoBut as you are pointing out, they took action on that thought. It was more than just fleeting.
- sangnoir 9y ago> But as you are pointing out, they took action on that thought They didn't take action if I correctly understood the allegory. If an organisation is a person (my friend...), then individual workers are like neurons/brain regions. This internal video is analogous to a thought that may or may not be acted out by creating a product that impacts other people outside of the org. I agree that the idea is dystopian, but the article was a little over the top with the scaremongering.
- godelski 9y agoMaking a video is action. It is not implementation, but it is definitely action.
- falcor84 9y agoOf course we're just arguing about semantics here, but I would absolutely argue that under the organisation-as-person metaphor, this video is absolutely not an "action" by the organism, but rather just part of its internal process. I'd say it's similar to how leading a military exercise does not actually constitute military action, unless you end up actually invading some place.
- wffurr 9y agoThe action alone is not what is judged. It is action and intent.