5 ms·
> This is nonsense. I really don't see what's so difficult to understand. Personal information is information to which the person can be identified. Does that
by jcranmer 9y ago
> This is nonsense. I really don't see what's so difficult to understand. Personal information is information to which the person can be identified.
Does that include email addresses and IP addresses? If so, that means things like using email addresses to log in for comments or logging IP addresses for traffic analysis causes all sorts of GDPR to kick in. As the OP points out, this means that things like the EU's own websites are in violation of the GDPR.
- jacquesm 9y ago> As the OP points out, this means that things like the EU's own websites are in violation of the GDPR. Actually, it doesn't. There are plenty of valid reasons to collect those things. Collecting them to track your users and to spam them to death are not on that list.
- ghein 9y agoThe presumption is that it's illegitimate but you can provide an affirmative defense of having a valid reason. Proving this can be expensive and is risky. Who knows what any individual judge in any EU country will decide is "reasonable"? Companies can easily be destroyed by filing multiple charges against them. Guilt, innocence, or reasonableness doesn't come into it: the process is the punishment. Look at Amanda Knox (Americans tend to think she's innocent, Brits tend to think she's guilty) - after appeals the Italian Justice System found her not guilty of the murder of her roommate. She still spent almost four years in prison in her early twenties and had to spend a huge amount of money on lawyers to arrive at this result. Just because you eventually get what you see as the right result doesn't mean you won't go through hell to get there. A major reason why Americans are having such a big problem with GDPR is because the EU system appears to change its interpretations and decisions abruptly, with retrospective effect. You set up companies in certain jurisdictions thanks to their tax rates and how transactions are treated. You follow every aspect of national and EU law. These arrangements are widely known, are accepted as legitimate practice, and they continue for decades. The EU commissioners change - suddenly your corporate arrangements are wildly illegal and you are subject to penalties and back taxes stretching over a decade. If staff changes and they say that they will interpret a rule differently going forward, you can adjust your behavior to comply. New legislation, sure abide by it. But when the rules change and your behavior 15 years ago is now viewed to be illegal you can't do anything. Retroactivity is accepted in Europe but it is explicitly unconstitutional in the US. It's a major reason why the US is not currently part of the UK. So the GDPR is terrifying because of the massive discretion granted to judges and prosecutors in every EU country and their habit for changing their interpretations. On its face it's not too threatening, but the fines are massive, there are no hard rules, and you can't be sure that today's interpretation will be tomorrow's. Facebook and Google will manage - they can write billion dollar checks and get the US government to protect them. Many of us can be completely wiped out by a $20MM fine. Just a court case would be existentially threatening in terms of the resources it requires and its impact on fundraising and gaining customers.
- jacquesm 9y agoMore fearmongering. I will simply wait to see what actually is being done and if and when that oversteps the bounds of what I consider reasonable I will definitely make my voice heard but until then this is all totally besides the point and time spent on fearmongering would probably be better spent on studying the law, determining its intent and then doing your best to comply with that intent. The very small chance that some mom & pop shop will be taken to the cleaners by the EU courts 'just because they can' strikes me as not grounded in reality, there is no precedent for anything like that. And bringing up some unrelated (murder!) case has no effect at all than to point out that justice systems aren't perfect, they are not expected to be perfect and we have lots of evidence to that effect already. That's a totally different discussion.
- ghein 9y agoThere's a presumption that every company in the world is violating EU citizens privacy. That storing IP addresses can be construed as illegal. That everyone is liable for a fine of $20MM for any mistake, innocent or malevolent. The EU itself is hyping up how fearsome this law is to win approval from their citizens and politicians. As well as to strongly encourage firms to take this change seriously. But I am at fault for taking the EU seriously rather than being blase. I am fearmongering for trying to explain why businesspeople who are not in the EU are afraid of its actions and are afraid of a brand new law that grants a huge amount of discretion to prosecutors and judges. What I know is that the EU can capriciously change its mind and go after the biggest companies for billions of dollars. I know that I don't have the resources to prove my innocence in a foreign country. I don't even have the resources to understand the charges against me, since legal translation is expensive and I could be faced with actions in any or all of the languages of the EU. If I get a package of documents in Estonian or Bulgarian I won't even know that I'm facing charges! Claiming universal jurisdiction against every company in the world with a reverse onus of proof is a dangerous and malevolent tactic. Because it's your local government that you have confidence in, you're comfortable with it. I doubt that you would be so blase about a similar approach by the US or Japan.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- corobo 9y agoYes it does. Indeed it also does mean the GDPR kicks in (on the 25th) All you need to be able to do though is say what you're using the information for. If that is "To allow you to log in to your account" and "Your IP and page requests are logged and kept for 2 weeks to for traffic analysis and troubleshooting" you're good to go - just say that on the sign-up form[1]. If you want add the email address to a mail list too you need to add an opt-in consent checkbox and a bit more information on what the checkbox agrees to. If you want to pass along the information (indirectly, I know) to Google Analytics for example then you have to mention that too, and don't load the GA snippets until the user has accepted that You also need a way to tell a user what data you have on them and delete the data where appropriate if the user requests it. You do not need to automate this process, chances are you'll never get either of those requests. Do Things That Don't Scale[2] applies when it comes to the user's ability to request info/deletion It's just another cost of doing business like if you want to take card payments don't store the card number without getting PCI compliant. Don't store user info without getting GDPR compliant. This whole thing is good for all of us as users of sites and software too [1] Actually for a signup form you don't need to say you're using the information to sign them in, that's "unambiguous consent", as long as you're not doing anything but registering them and signing them in you can avoid clogging up your form with that information [2] http://paulgraham.com/ds.html http://paulgraham.com/ds.html
- frockington 9y agoWon't this just lead to more thousand page long sign up forms that nobody reads? I could easily right 10 pages on the reason behind using an email address at signup and hide in a bunch of seemingly mundane details
- corobo 9y agoNo, that's also a part of GDPR - They have to be understandable. 300 page documents with a position:fixed "I agree" button don't cover you As with all things GDPR you can of course try to skirt the rules but you're risking the 20mil fine if you don't get it absolutely spot on