4 ms·
One of my great grandmothers worked in a button factory as a child. My grandfather on that side was able to go to college because of The Cooper Union. It was ex
by brudgers 9y ago
One of my great grandmothers worked in a button factory as a child. My grandfather on that side was able to go to college because of The Cooper Union. It was explicitly non-lamarkian. As is all social mobility. Google's vision literally pairs the idea that the options offered children will be bounded by the data trail of their parents with the image of a man working on a row boat. A literal interpretation -- the only kind computers make -- suggests that the artifacts this system will produce for the man's children are more likely to be oars than iPads. That's not to say this fetishization of Lamarkian genetics doesn't make sense inside Google. The median salary for the people there is $200,000 and the system will probably cough up Hondas if not BMW's. Google's vision reduces to using computation to create and maintain a caste system. The image of the man in the boat is a deliberate design decision.
- sneak 9y agoThe video does not examine the idea that “locally grown” produce may actually be a net negative to society, both bringing up the problems inherent in “global good” then proceeding in the next breath without addressing any of them, carrying on as if they don’t exist. It’s a clever instance of self-deception.
- GuiA 9y ago> That's not to say this fetishization of Lamarkian genetics doesn't make sense inside Google. The median salary for the people there is $200,000 and the system will probably cough up Hondas if not BMW's. This is a problem I have with all tech companies who are designing products used by hundreds of millions, if not billions, of humans - ranging from farmers in Germany to factory workers in India or mothers in Ecuador or ... How can the employees of those companies - a group of people who are used to driving Teslas, getting their groceries delivered, etc - relate to those users and understand them in any meaningful way at all?(replying that a bunch of Google UX designers once spent 3 days in the Philippines doing “user research” is a terrible answer)