Am I the only one who prefers the "naked" screenshot (https://www.screely.com/img/before3.png https://www.screely.com/img/before3.png) over the one with gimmick

Am I the only one who prefers the "naked" screenshot (https://www.screely.com/img/before3.png https://www.screely.com/img/before3.png) over the one with gimmicks? (https://www.screely.com/img/after3.png https://www.screely.com/img/after3.png) The gimmicks blow up the file size (especially when/if they add an alpha channel only for the shadow) and don't look better in every scenario. I think such decoration should be applied when neccessary, for instance with CSS within a website.