4 ms·
> You mean not explain complicated technical matters to congressmen at all, so they will be making decisions in complete ignorance? I'm not sure you've thought
by naasking 9y ago
> You mean not explain complicated technical matters to congressmen at all, so they will be making decisions in complete ignorance?
I'm not sure you've thought this through. Consider:
1. Representatives voting in complete ignorance would vote 50/50, on average. However, some representatives will actually have the technical knowledge needed to vote properly, so the majority would probably fall in NN's favour. What do you think the vote ratio would look like if they only received biased information from lobbyists with deep pockets? Suddenly voting in ignorance doesn't sound too bad (and this applies to any issue, not just NN).
2. To further the above point, the wisdom of the crowd is a robust phenomenon whereby a group of independent voters can make better aggregate decisions than any single voter, probably for exactly the reasons I explained above. However, this breaks down if the votes are no longer independent. Lobbying destroys this property. If you look up the "wisdom of the crowds", lobbying encourages homogeneity, centralization, imitation, and emotionality.
- dnadler 9y ago> Representatives voting in complete ignorance would vote 50/50, on average I suspect that there would be a strong status quo bias in ignorant votes, so 50/50 is not a realistic assumption in my opinion. Not that this is even a realistic starting point to begin with because interested parties will alway try to disseminate information to law makers (directly, or indirectly).
- naasking 9y ago> I suspect that there would be a strong status quo bias in ignorant votes Not sure about that. If the status quo were satisfactory, it's less likely there would be a vote to change it. That's a counterbalancing impetus to vote away from the status quo. Hard to quantify which way that would fall. Furthermore, outlawing lobbying would encourage the contrary behaviour for candidates to keep their seats: the representatives visiting their constituents to hear their views. Lobbyists can voice their opinion at these town hall meetings, and I think it's clear that this makes it much harder to game the votes away from constituent interests. The significant expansion of meetings to cover to stack the deck makes lobbying considerably more expensive, and probably not worth it unless it's a seriously important issue that would make or break a market.
- smsm42 9y ago> Representatives voting in complete ignorance would vote 50/50, on average. Why? > However, some representatives will actually have the technical knowledge needed to vote properly By "properly", you mean "agreeing with me", right? This does not require any technical knowledge. > so the majority would probably fall in NN's favour. You implying everybody that has technical knowledge supports NN, and only reason to oppose it is ignorance. This is wrong and incredibly condescending. > What do you think the vote ratio would look like if they only received biased information from lobbyists Depends on how biased it is. If it's biased in favor of NN, the ratio would be something different than if it's biased against NN. > Suddenly voting in ignorance doesn't sound too bad Yes it does. Why would we need any Congress at all then? We could replace them with a cheap one cent coin and save a lot of money and drama. The point of representative government is that it is a focus point of an effort to figure out the right thing to do, and that all participants at least kinda trying to do it. If it's just random, there's no point of wasting effort on it, we can do much better random much cheaper. > whereby a group of independent voters can make better aggregate decisions than any single voter, I agree, having elections makes more sense than having a King. > However, this breaks down if the votes are no longer independent. Nobody is truly independent in a modern society. Not even a King - historically, there were lots of weak monarchs manipulated by their courts and seconds in command. Neither a person living in a modern society. Of course people influence other people. And this can produce negative effects like groupthink and mass panics. So what's your suggestion - ban talking about politics? Mind-wiping congressmen before voting?
- naasking 9y ago> By "properly", you mean "agreeing with me", right? I mean in the interests of their constituents. > You implying everybody that has technical knowledge supports NN, and only reason to oppose it is ignorance. This is wrong and incredibly condescending. I imply nothing of the sort, but the majority of people certainly favour NN. > Yes it does. Why would we need any Congress at all then? We could replace them with a cheap one cent coin and save a lot of money and drama. [...] If it's just random, there's no point of wasting effort on it, we can do much better random much cheaper. Except it's not random, as I explained.