3 ms·
I'd much prefer a basic job guarantee. Instead of just giving out free money, taken from the productive, the government is obligated to give a basic job to all
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I'd much prefer a basic job guarantee. Instead of just giving out free money, taken from the productive, the government is obligated to give a basic job to all comers.
That job could take many forms - cleaning courthouses and prisons for the unskilled, DMV clerk for the skilled. But it is important that the job be unpleasant and low paid, so that people have an incentive to seek more useful jobs in the private sector.
Basic jobs fulfills the same goals as basic income (no one is destitute) while reducing the disincentives to work that basic income creates.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoIt's interesting that your other posts are so libertarian but here you're essentially proposing what the USSR promised its citizens. http://www.departments.bucknell.edu/russian/const/77cons02.html http://www.departments.bucknell.edu/russian/const/77cons02.h... (Article 40)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm proposing a form of help which is fairly cheap (some of the work is stuff the govt would pay for anyway) and has good incentives [1]. For this reason, basic jobs would be a great substitute for unemployment, welfare, etc. Just because I generally want the government to do less doesn't mean that I don't want them to do things efficiently and with as few unwanted side effects as possible. The fact that the USSR did it doesn't make it bad policy - that's the reverse Mussolini fallacy. It would also not be a bad thing to make the trains run on time. [1] For comparison, unemployment insurance creates bad incentives. Rather than looking for work, the woman described in this article went on vacation while collecting unemployment. Replacing unemployment with a "basic jobs" program would prevent this.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoAfter 20 years working as an office flunky for Boeing, I'd take a vacation, too...
- Retric 16y agoThere is zero incentive to stay unemployed because you get the same money regardless of age or employment. Chances are she would have taken the same vacation, and then gotten a lower paying job sooner. PS: It's also a smaller paycheck than SS or unemployment so it's harder to get by without a job.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIt's a disincentive to work because of diminishing marginal utility - your second $10,000 of income is not as valuable to you as your first $10,000 of income. If the second $10k/year is less valuable to you than leisure, you will avoid work. If she got neither unemployment nor basic income, but only basic work, the taxpayers would not have been forced to pay for her vacation.
- gmlk 16y ago(1) Being payed is not equivalent with being productive There is a whole lot of work being done by the so called unemployed which really needs to be done but for which no-one is going to pay them. If anything open source should have proven is that while there is a lot of valuable work to be done, no-one is willing to pay for it being done, especially not in the startup phase when it's not even clear what you are working on. Fundamental work is often overlooked because it only becomes clear how to make it profitable after it is made. Many people are payed while they are totally unproductive, while many of the most productive people are not payed any more, often even a lot less, then the unproductive people. Crap often sells better then quality work. (2) Full employment is an illusion There will never be 100% employment, more and more people will find themselves unable to find employment. Currently there is no safety net for the self-employed. (3) An unconditional basic income is about basic freedom and what this means in the 21th century. With an unconditional basic income we take worrying about survival of the table. Survival is something that should not be a worry in the civilized world. A basic income is a general safety net for any mishap, misfortune and plain bad luck than could happen to anyone. (4) An unconditional basic income is about human dignity. Giving people options that they don't have today: The freedom to quite an unhealthy, low paying, dead-end job and to look for something worth doing. Even if this is something like developing open source software, or some other creative endeavor.In the end more value is created even if no-one was told to do it.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoRegarding 2) and 3), my proposed "Basic Job" provides that. Everyone will be eligible for the Basic Job, including the formerly self employed and the unlucky, and no one needs to worry about survival. As for 1) and 4), you seem to believe that there are a huge number of budding Linus Torvald's out in the world, being held down by their corporate 9-5 job. I think that's bunk. If you think I'm wrong, you should be able to prove it easily. Many people do have some variant on basic income: NYC teachers in the rubber rooms, auto workers in the no-job banks, not to mention the vast European welfare class. Could you point out to me some contributions to the open source world from such people?
- gmlk 16y ago