4 ms·
>> When the dog gets close to the wire, the receiver starts to beep, and when the dog gets all the way to the “fence” boundary, the receiver generates a small e
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> When the dog gets close to the wire, the receiver starts to beep, and when the dog gets all the way to the “fence” boundary, the receiver generates a small electric zap. I know, I know … it’s negative reinforcement and it’s a shock collar and all that. Don’t care. It’s fantastic for us and our dogs.
That's disgusting.
- raverbashing 9y agoDo you know what's worse? Your dog straying out of the farm and getting eaten by a bear. Or run over by a truck
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoOh it's for the dog's own good? Well in that case you can lock it up in a pen so it can't get out, or the bears come in. That will keep it safe. Nothing wrong with that, is there?
- brazzy 9y agoWhat exactly are you arguing for?
- raverbashing 9y agoThanks, that was hilarious.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoYou're welcome, I can see you were eager to engage in meaningful conversation.
- solotronics 9y agoHow would you keep a dog from straying into the wild and getting injured? These are pets and not wild animals able to survive in the bush on their own.
- oldandtired 9y agoTalking with a friend recently about how "wild" our pet dogs are. In the local area, dogs get out at night and form packs that hunt calves and lambs and simply kill them and leave the bodies. There is a good business in hunting feral cats and dogs that were pets and have been left to fend for themselves in the wild because they were no longer wanted.
- rlonstein 9y agoIt's changed as the demographics shifted and the county urbanized but thirty years ago the local sheriff still issued deputy animal control papers to hunters, farmers, woodsmen, etc. who reported dog packs. There are fewer farms, greater housing density, more posted land, revised laws, and different attitudes toward animal control (generally, better) but the problem still occasionally comes up. Feral dogs aren't just a semi-rural problem, this was the situation in Brooklyn https://gowanuslounge.blogspot.com/2007/07/dog-days-remember-red-hook-gowanus-wild.html https://gowanuslounge.blogspot.com/2007/07/dog-days-remember... and resulted in a handful of publicized attacks on joggers and pets.
- maxerickson 9y agoHere the feral dog problem is solved enough that there's a substantial population of rabbits living in town. (a small town in a rural county)
- vvanders 9y agoYup, many dog owners I know are shocked to find out that it's legal in most states to kill a dog that's harassing livestock(hasn't yet done physical harm).
- oldandtired 9y agoThe dogs I referred to are not feral as such. They are pets to someone. It is when they get together in packs that their behaviour goes wild. The owners are often unaware that their dogs have wandered about and partaken in killing of stock. It is also applicable to cats.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simias 9y agoI had the same initial reaction but then again I don't have a dog nor do I have a large enough estate to ever need such a device anyway. Clearly I don't have the data to weigh in on this issue. That being said if you consider that having dogs in a very large outdoors environment with a colar that zaps them (after warning them) if they stray too far is abuse, then isn't keeping the same dog in a small cramped urban flat much, much worse? If I was the dog I know what I'd choose. That being said I think if I was in their position (and again, I'm very far from it) I think I'd prefer having an actual physical fence.
- crummy 9y agoFor what it's worth, my folks have an actual physical fence but it is just insufficient. The dog would always figure out a way through or under or over it. The shock collar is also not perfect but far more effective.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoOne thing that's far more effective is tying the dog up to a pole and never letting it roam free. Is there an objection to handling a dog in this manner?
- crummy 9y agoAll day? I guess I'm making an assumption here about the internal desires of a dog but I think she'd prefer to roam several hectares, even with the risk of an electrical shock, rather than be tied to a stick.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoMaybe she would prefer to roam free behind an ordinary fence and not have to risk an electrical shock? The reason this is used instead of a fence has nothing to do with the dog's preferences (which of course we can't know), safety, or convenience. Instead, the reason seems to be cost. I don't see how it's possible to justify avoiding the cost of building a fence by mistreating your animals. If the man who has this farm can't keep dogs without delivering electric shocks to them, then maybe he shouldn't have any dogs.
- gldalmaso 9y agoAs a nitpick, if I recall correctly, "negative reinforcement" is when you remove a desirable stimulus to reinforce behavior. In this case it's actually "positive punishment" as they are introducing an aversive stimulus to extinguish some behavior (go out of bounds). https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-punishment-2795413 https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-punishment-2795413
- megaman22 9y agoIt's less disgusting than seeing your poor dog smashed to hamburg by a pulp truck in the road, or put down by animal control because it wandered off and got antagonized.