4 ms·
Japan is basically an honorary European nation as far as the West cares. They kind of earned it. Ever since they realized they were behind in the 1800s they'v
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
Japan is basically an honorary European nation as far as the West cares. They kind of earned it. Ever since they realized they were behind in the 1800s they've done everything the western nations have done (good and bad) and done them as well or better.
- perfmode 9y agoIn one sense, this comment... is holding Japan in a great light but also looking down on it as though Europe is in a position to confer honor a Western point of view
- Retra 9y agoEveryone is in a position to confer honor. You just happen to be on a western website witnessing it.
- oculusthrift 9y agowhether you like it or not the world still revolves around the west. even if it is less so than in the past, militarily and economically the world is led by the west.
- coldtea 9y ago>whether you like it or not the world still revolves around the west People in the west like to think that. After one has lived for a while in an Asian, African, Latin American etc country, they get to see that billions of people, the 80% of the global population, could and don't give a fuck about the going's on in the west -- except when they're forced to deal with it (e.g. militarily). E.g. the Chinese might care for selling to US/Europe -- but that doesn't mean they also care for our beliefs, history, philosophy, moral outrages, outlook on life, charts, stars, concerns, or any other such thing that we take as some kind of "physical law".
- poisonarena 9y agoNo way.. I have spent the last 6 years living in Mexico, Colombia, and Japan. Our culture dominates, absolutely. They strive, especially in Mexico and Colombia, to be like us in the West.
- coldtea 9y agoIf you mean in trying to make money as well, have luxuries like in the West and things like that, that has been a global concern since before West and East were met. Even so, Mexico is next to the states and has some millions of US immigrants and wannabe immigrants, and still -- they have their own culture, morals, etc, and the typical western concerns are not their thing. So, I was talking more about the cultural and societal aspects. They'll still watch some popular Hollywood movie or have teenagers listening to Cardie B, but they live in their own, different, world, as oblivious to the West as a Oklahoman farmer or a NY gallery owner is oblivious to them and their world.
- poisonarena 9y agoYou should do some traveling to major cities in Latin America.
- gkya 9y agoPlease explain how Columbia or Mexico is not west, goegraphically or culturally.
- coldtea 9y agoWest is not a geography, it's a state of mind (and a history). Geopolitically it just refers to US/Canada and Europe (and perhaps Japan). Mexico and Columbia belong to the Latin American world -- which has diversity within it, of course, but Europe for one, also has. It's a quite old distinction that's used all the time. See how Wikipedia maps the "Western world": "(...) what is known today as described by the term "The West": United States of America and Canada, European Union and European Free Trade Association member states, Israel, Australia and New Zealand" and: "The term "Western world" is sometimes interchangeably used with the term First World or developed countries, stressing the difference between First World and the Third World or developing countries." (which also doesn't include Mexico and Columbia) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_world https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_world https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_World
- swebs 9y ago>Japan is basically an honorary European nation as far as the West cares. >[that is] a Western point of view ???
- joncampbelldev 9y agoThis comment would be less silly if the above hadn't made it clear that the "honour" is entirely from a western point of view. It is then up to any japanese / non-western readers whether they give a shit about the honour conferred by some westerners. Honour (like most things) is subjective and varies from culture to culture. Perhaps the day a universal register of honour is established you can post your comment again when some westerner applies to give honour to the japanese again.
- stephengillie 9y agoThey started with invading German islands in the Pacific Ocean in WW1 - this got them into the League of Nations. This was just 20 years after they invaded Korea and the Liaodong peninsula, and just 50 years after the Meiji revolution ended Samurai culture. The turnabout in culture is very remarkable.
- nkoren 9y agoThey started well before then, with the Russo-Japanese war in 1904. 36 years after the Meiji restoration, they took on Russia and won. Not that military prowess should necessarily be the metric of civilisation, but Japan was/is a damned impressive culture by that metric, as well as many others.
- stephengillie 9y agoRussia was hoping to get a warm-water port in the bay between Liaodong and Korea. Too bad Japan was already there, having invaded 8 years prior.
- merinowool 9y agoEspecially running concentration camps and ethnic cleansing some western nations are known for.