4 ms·
OK, I've been meaning to ask the HN community about this. Please share your thoughts. Wouldn't it make a lot of sense for Google (et al) to have this sort of a
by ez77 16y ago
OK, I've been meaning to ask the HN community about this. Please share your thoughts.
Wouldn't it make a lot of sense for Google (et al) to have this sort of authentication every time you want to change your Google Accounts password? Isn't this a pretty safe way to prevent being locked out should someone gain access to your account?
You may be thinking about costs, but this could easily be a premium service I would gladly pay for! For instance, I could charge $10 to my account, which should allow me plenty of password changes in the future. An intruder may "waste" at most one SMS, since he would not have it and until then Google should not send you any additional SMSs. Does it make sense? If it does, you Googlers in here, please pass it on!
While we're at it... how about extending this to domain registrars? This would be even more critical. I must say it, I'm pretty paranoid and by now it clearly shows. I don't know how you guys have launched successful websites and cope with this lack of safety features. I know I'm rambling, but please speak your mind on this issue.
PS: I realize things are not so bad as they could be, that probably keyloggers are rather hard to plant, etc. But it wouldn't hurt to have these features, and the companies involved would only profit, both financially and in terms of reliability.
- omh 16y agoWith OpenID, I wonder whether people would appreciate the option to "outsource" their authentication. If places like domain registrars supported it then people could take the option most convenient for them. Some people would just use OpenID to their email provider, others could pick providers who use two-factor auth of various kinds (and pay for the extra SMS costs there, without the site themselves having to support it). The really paranoid could have SecurID-style keyfobs for every site if they wanted to.
- borism 16y agodo you realize 2-factor authentification has nothing to do with changing passwords?
- ez77 16y agoYes. My humble proposal is that it should. Do you think it would be ineffective, or a bad idea? If so, why?
- borism 16y agoWell, since two-factor authentification is required to login into your account to change password, I would think it already applies to password change?
- kgermino 16y agoI believe ez77 is saying to make it so that the 2 factor auth. comes every time you try to change your password whereas this seems to be designed to only be used the first time you use a computer with an account. I may be mistaken though.