27 ms·
I've recently been contemplating two separate problems we have in this country, and I think I've come up with a partial solution to both. Problem 1: Illegal im
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I've recently been contemplating two separate problems we have in this country, and I think I've come up with a partial solution to both.
Problem 1: Illegal immigrants.
Problem 2: Americans who can't find a job.
This seems like a matching problem. I propose that DHS crack down hard on employers of illegal immigrants. To solve problem 2, they must coordinate with local unemployment agencies. DHS will arrest and deport illegal immigrants. For each illegal thus deported, the unemployment benefits of an American (maybe whoever has been on unemployment the longest) will be terminated and they will be ordered to report to work at the former employer of the illegal. Employing a formerly unemployed American will be part of the penalty for the employer of the illegal immigrant.
To induce cooperation among employers, we could create an amnesty program. Employers can report their illegal workers to DHS and avoid paying fines. Maybe DHS/Unemployment Office will even give extra help to minimize disruption to your business (i.e., no deportation until the day replacements are available).
[edit: to those downmodding, just curious. Is there an obvious flaw in my plan that I'm missing?]
- JustinSeriously 16y agoI didn't downmod you, but a couple potential issues are: - The job market isn't always a zero-sum game, so immigrants aren't always "stealing" jobs from citizens. - Illegal immigrants are often in low-paying jobs involving manual labor, jobs that many citizens wouldn't consider even if they were available. (Anecdotally, I know one landscaping company that offers all their jobs to legal immigrants/citizens first, and if no one takes them they go to H-1B visas, and if those run out they start looking at illegal immigrants.)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn the short term, it is zero sum. In the long run, I agree with you. Therefore, such a scheme would be best used only for people who have been unemployed for a reasonably long period of time (say, 6 weeks). As for citizens being unwilling to accept available jobs, why should the taxpayer be forced to pay unemployment benefits to people who are unwilling to work?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]