5 ms·
But they aren't determining international commerce policy. The coal companies are free to ship it out through Texas, or Wyoming, or wherever will have them. Th
by vkou 9y ago
But they aren't determining international commerce policy. The coal companies are free to ship it out through Texas, or Wyoming, or wherever will have them.
There's a difference between "I don't want guns in my house" and "I want guns to be banned in my country."
It's not Oakland's responsibility to ensure that the coal industry can make money in Oakland.
- aje403 9y agoIf we're going to use invalid analogies, there's also a big difference between "I declare murder to be legal in the home that I own!" and "I think murder should be legalized!"
- bcheung 9y agoSuch reasoning is detrimental to a free society. It's not a house, it's a port. And a major one at that. Should ISPs be free to discriminate and ban anything they don't like too?
- fiter 9y agoThe government does regulate what ISPs can host. In this case, the local government is trying to regulate what the port can host.
- AmericanChopper 9y agoShould cities where fiber cables land be able to regulate what packets pass through them?
- fiter 9y agoYour original statement was that ISPs should not get to ban. I noted that ISPs might not get to ban, but governments do get to ban. You are now asking me if governments should get to ban. I believe I already said that they do get to ban. If your point is that you believe specifically cities should not be able to ban, then maybe that should be the case. I'd like to hear your argument, though.
- AmericanChopper 9y agoYou're actually replying to a different person. But in any case, giving local government the power to arbitrarily deny access to national infrastructure is a terrible idea, and it would allow local government to override any national foreign trade strategies, amongst other things. There's lots of major exchange points on the west coast, should the cities where they're located have a say on what packets they handle? Do you think your requests should be dropped if the City of San Jose doesn't want to serve them for you? Because that's no different than this.
- mikeash 9y agoOakland owns this “national infrastructure” so it doesn’t seem at all like San Jose dropping my requests, unless they own the network.
- AmericanChopper 9y agoThis point is entirely contrived. California owns all of the interstates within it's borders, are they also "national infrastructure"? Do you think California should be able to dictate what goods can and cannot be transported on them? Numerous private companies own the fiber cables and exchanges that deliver internet across the country, are they "national infrastructure" too? In this case a local council is trying to control what goods can and cannot be imported out of America, something which it does not and should not have the power to do. Edit: in case it’s not clear, your “unless they own the network” remark is an assertion that Net Neitrality should not exist in any form.
- mikeash 9y ago“Edit: in case it’s not clear, your “unless they own the network” remark is an assertion that Net Neitrality should not exist in any form.” Excuse me? I was describing what would be needed for your comparison to make sense. There’s no sensible path from that to “Net Neutrality should not exist in any form.”
- mikeash 9y agoThe only reason we need regulations to stop ISPs from banning things is because there isn’t enough competition to make it happen naturally. This is not the case with ports.