3 ms·
But the political problem is that you need far more money to build transit than can be achieved with VC money. Unless a startup has managed to somehow reduce th
by bobthepanda 9y ago
But the political problem is that you need far more money to build transit than can be achieved with VC money. Unless a startup has managed to somehow reduce the cost of right-of-way acquisition it's not a solution that keeps the cost of developing transit down.
There was a model that worked; transit has historically been used to allow property development. This was used in the development of London, Hong Kong, Tokyo, New York, and the multitudes of inner-ring streetcar suburbs in American metropolitan areas. The problem is that whereas Hong Kong and Tokyo held onto the properties, Western companies that used this model tended to just sell off the property, requiring Ponzi-scheme levels of land acquisition. That collapsed when they ran out of money and the federal government started building free interstates to goose the suburb-building instead. And now in 2018 there's very little cheap farmland within sane rail commuting distance of metro areas, and the model doesn't work in places like New York where a block of property acquisition is equivalent to building an entire train line. Even Tokyo has stopped building new railways using this model because it just does not scale.
- vinceguidry 9y agoMy understanding is that the problem with transit isn't just a resource problem, you literally need the power of the state to invoke eminent domain in order to build the infrastructure, making it a purely political problem that can only be solved by using political channels. And the model you list is still in use today, if you take into account that roads are also 'transit'. It's just not the kind of transit that you and I want to see implemented.
- bobthepanda 9y agoWell roads are not built privately. And we're starting to see what happened with the earlier streetcar model, where the one-off revenue from property development is not enough to pay for the infrastructure in perpetuity. The eminent domain thing is a power of the state, but it's also true that even if you were to privatize railroads today, they could not afford to purchase all the required property for new lines at fair market value. Hence the dependence on the government to front that cost instead.