5 ms·
Both the UN and the EU consider privacy a fundamental human right. We shouldn't be looking for a law, we should be looking for a Constitutional Amendment.
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
Both the UN and the EU consider privacy a fundamental human right. We shouldn't be looking for a law, we should be looking for a Constitutional Amendment.
- strictnein 9y agoIt would be improper to limit individuals in their interactions with other individuals or corporations via an amendment. A law is the proper place for that type of restriction.
- gowld 9y agoYou are getting reflexively downvoted, but it's not so clear cut. On the one hand, slavery was banned by 13th amendment. On the middle handle, alcohol was banned (18th) and then unbanned (21st) by amendment. On the other hand, nearly everything else in the Constitution is about the function of government and the rights of individuals with respect to government, not the rights of individuals with respect to other individuals.
- glup 9y agoTo clarify: your argument is that by precedent with existing amendments, the US Constitution should be limited to interactions with the state?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoWe should arguably guarantee a right to privacy in the Constitution first, as we should have the same protections from government as well. (As our other human rights are generally protected via the Constitution.) Then, if it is viewed as improper to do so via Amendment, additional laws can be passed to apply it to private entities as well, much as the Civil Rights Act of 1964 builds on the 14th Amendment.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Both the UN and the EU consider privacy a fundamental human right Privacy and free speech exist in natural conflict. Between the two, I prefer our society which enshrines the latter over the former to the European model which does the reverse.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAbsolutely wrong. The two do not exist in any sort of conflict whatsoever.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The two do not exist in any sort of conflict whatsoever The "right to be forgotten” debate [1] neatly encapsulates this conflict. Journalists' rights to pry versus citizens' rights to avoid being pried on is another example [2]. This is a balancing act. Excessive privacy restricts what third parties can talk about. Unrestricted speech means anyone can say everything they know (or know to be false) about others' private lives. There are multiple equilibria. But acknowledging the trade-off is a pre-requisite to writing good law. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten [2] https://www.economist.com/node/18621060 https://www.economist.com/node/18621060
- mLuby 9y agoFree speech is not the same as violating someone's privacy (whether as a journalist or a doxxer).
- Matticus_Rex 9y agoYou're begging the question in both your definition of free speech and assuming a certain bundle of privacy rights. There's plenty to debate on what speech freedoms people should have and what privacy rights people should have, but it's silly to claim that there's no conflict between them conceptually; if you're stating that there's no conflict, you're assuming a certain set of each, which is just you defining the problem a certain way so that you can say it is solved. If other people don't agree with your definition of the problem, then your solution doesn't hold for them.
- mLuby 9y agoFair enough. I'm drawing a distinction between free speech (specifically parrhesia, which is orthogonal to privacy) and freedom to learn anything about anyone (which is antithetical to privacy). In journalism they are combined, usually to good effect; in doxxing the combination is bad.