48 ms·
Startup Wants to Replace Cars and Subways with Elevated Pods
- nmeofthestate 9y ago"Solar Powered" - why? Why not decouple this from power generation, put the solar cells in the most efficient place, and just make this system electric powered? Tracks will presumably be situated deep in urban canyons and in shade for a lot of the time. Gotta crowbar in those green buzzwords.
- timerol 9y agoIn their handbook (http://transitx.com/transitxhandbook.pdf http://transitx.com/transitxhandbook.pdf), they admit that was purely for marketing. "If there is insufficient solar energy available, Transit X will use other sources of sustainable energy."
- djrogers 9y agoWait a sec - it's solar powered and the posts hold the batteries, but the pods have to charge? Also, the 100lb pods seat 5, but theay're barely big enough to seat 2 people who are apparently carry little to nothing? There's no way a 100lb pod contains batteries and a drive mechanism capable of moving 5 people and their stuff up and down hills, so is the drive mechanism in the tracks? If so, why would the pods need to be recharged? Seems like a neat idea, but it's clearly vaporware if even the marketing stuff is contradictory and/or impossible with today's tech.
- timerol 9y agoThey do claim specific numbers in their handbook (http://transitx.com/transitxhandbook.pdf http://transitx.com/transitxhandbook.pdf): 20 lbs battery, 2 electric motors driving 4 15cm wheels, with a max load of 800 lbs. (4 adults or 8 children). Whether that's reasonable or not is up for debate... My guess is that these pods need an extremely level track.
- apendleton 9y agoAs to reasonableness: I spent a couple summers in college working for helicopter sightseeing companies in Alaska. Part of my job was doing flight manifests, assigning passengers to aircraft with an eye towards weight maximums, and we had passengers from all over the world. Not to reinforce stereotypes, but from that experience, these numbers are probably reasonable for their target launch market (Manila), and would probably also be fine for other Asian markets. For US markets, this would be tight, but not that tight if they didn't have much stuff. Your average group of four Americans probably has somebody in it that weighs more than 200lbs, but others who weigh less; still, groups of four Americans traveling together that all weigh more than that were not uncommon, so at these limits passengers would need to be cognizant of their weight and the overall weight max before boarding. If it were me I'd probably market them as 3 passengers max in the US just to be on the safe side.
- djrogers 9y ago20lbs of batteries leaves 80lbs for the rest of the structure and the motors - a structure that is supposed to enclose and support 800 lbs? That seems very, very optimistic. As does the 150MPH speed! 20lbs of current-tech batteries would only provide enough power to run for a few minutes at those speeds..
- jessaustin 9y agoNobody wants to navigate 90° intersections at 40mph, let alone 150mph...
- mozumder 9y agoAutoman does: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kA1NT4I0s34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kA1NT4I0s34
- blang 9y agoIsn't a company called SkyTran trying to do the same thing?
- magduf 9y agoBasically, yes, except that SkyTran has been around for many years (since the 90s I think), and their system uses elevated maglev rails, not wheels (wheels are used at low speeds). Unfortunately, SkyTran hasn't gotten too far either; they're supposedly building a test track in Tel Aviv that will be finished in 2015... This company looks like total vaporware stealing the SkyTran concept.
- leoedin 9y agoThis seems a lot like the "Ultra PRT" pods which are currently installed at London Heathrow. http://www.ultraglobalprt.com/how-it-works/ultra-vehicle/ http://www.ultraglobalprt.com/how-it-works/ultra-vehicle/ They're probably facing the same problems that face all infrastructure heavy public transport projects - huge capex and very little money available for this type of unproven project.
- mrguyorama 9y agoTom Scott gives a good overview of these and the ones at a University in West Virginia: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaSaWfw07Sw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaSaWfw07Sw
- fluxsauce 9y agoA modern monorail? Literally, looking at the mockup imagery. This is personal transit, not mass transit and I don't see it solving problems in major metropolitan areas.
- JBReefer 9y agoI don't think anyone wants to solve the hard problems of mass transit, I think people are looking for cheap workarounds. Everyone wants to start the next Uber, and this is a major unsolved problem. However, the history of failed private transportation ideas is really interesting, and really detrimental to the stuff that actually works: walkable areas, biking, trains, buses, etc. Hell, there's a suburb outside of Miami that just vetoed a rail project because "self driving cars are right around the corner!" which sure sounds like the flying car predictions of the 50s-70s.
- magduf 9y agoTrains and buses don't really work unless your density is extremely high. Not everyone wants to go between the same small set of points along a linear route. This is one reason why cars are much more efficient for many routes. Personal Rapid Transit offers the decentralized nature of cars, but eliminated many of its problems: having to stop at stoplights, the limitations of human drivers, etc. It can't handle huge masses of people the way a train can, but for suburban use it would really be a lot better than cars, and it would also be a much better option for higher-paying passengers than traditional cabs or Uber/Lyft.
- homerowilson 9y agocompare with the cool vintage Morgantown PRT: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgantown_Personal_Rapid_Transit https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgantown_Personal_Rapid_Tr...
- misterbwong 9y agoSerious question: Why can't we, at least on freeways, build (either virtual/software based or physical/metal) rails into the road, and "self drive" them autopia-style? It would allow us to retrofit all vehicles, regardless of year made, would allow fully autonomous driving on freeways, and would also solve the last mile problem of public transportation by allow cars to simply drive that last mile as normal. Is the infrastructure investment too high? Does this not scale?
- rbranson 9y agoThat doesn’t solve the traffic problem, which is what the company is addressing.
- everdev 9y agoIt might help traffic because cars could move in tandem and follow closer behind. I think exiting the highway and going from "rail mode" to "driving mode" would be the trickiest part. I'd imagine you'd need some manual signal from the driver to the rail system to confirm that the driver is sort and ready to take back over.
- MisterTea 9y agoI think the big problem would be how do you change lanes?
- themmes 9y agoActually, that is not the problem and they are testing this in Stockholm, Sweden[1]. [1] https://www.dezeen.com/2018/04/23/electric-car-charging-road-opens-stockholm-sweden/ https://www.dezeen.com/2018/04/23/electric-car-charging-road...
- ksk 9y agoCould you elaborate? I read the linked article, and it didn't explain anything to me. How does it work when you change lanes at 60-70mph?
- Tiktaalik 9y agoAnother company wasting its time reinventing the wheel. We solved these issues in the 19th century. Our transportation problems are political, not technological problems. The problem is the lack of political will to fund and build public transportation and active transportation systems instead of continuously expanding the road network.
- josephpmay 9y agoIt is a political problem... BUT Subways are expensive to build, and expensive to maintain. If a technological solution makes implementing public transportation cheaper, I think that's a good thing Edit: Also, Subways work well in dense city areas, but are less efficient is places like LA (outside of downtown) that are very spread out
- vinceguidry 9y agoIt's becoming increasingly common to use "it's a political problem" as a conversation-ender, as if political problems can't be worked on and solved. We already have several examples of how political problems can be hacked on and overcome. Uber's early days where they were busy opening up cities to the idea of a competing taxi service. There's also the traditional way, activism. Activism seems to work best drumming up political support for social problems. Problems like this one tend to respond well to large sums of money collected to fund a trial run. Find just one city to try this out on. Public transit's big problem is that it's been tried, and while it works, it requires huge amounts of political capital to be created and spent on each expansion of the transit network. A profit motive would allow this process to expand at the rate of demand. But so far, transit is akin to utilities in that there's a real public interest in keeping prices down. Plus the transit agenda can get weirdly partisan. Here in Atlanta, the majority-white northern suburbs did not want MARTA train stations going too deeply northward. The pejorative expansion of the acronym was "Moving Africans rapidly through Atlanta." So we need more Ubers in the world, companies that are not afraid to challenge political institutions in order to drive the public interest forward. The profit motive is needed in order to drive expansion, and the legal regime needs to be flexible enough to get around NIMBY naysayers.
- 9y ago
- lachdoug 9y agoGermany's Cabinentaxi was the first on-demand rapid personal transit system. They may not have solved the personal transport problem, but they built an impressive test track and made a great promo video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERdF0FK-2io https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERdF0FK-2io
- eisen 9y agoI would love to see this be pitched to an american city. Response: 25% of americans won’t be able to fit in this...
- brixon 9y agoTypically "4 people" would equate "2 Americans". Granted, big cities tend to have lighter people than rural areas, so it is less of an issue. Or we an always American size it.
- chiph 9y agoThere's a group of wealthy people in Austin proposing a Heathrow Pod-like system. I'm skeptical that it can handle the large surge of passengers from a large music venue or Circuit of the Americas.
- joveian 9y agoThere was one of these companies in Minnesota for three decades, but it looks like it dissolved earlier this year: https://finance-commerce.com/2018/04/the-transit-revolution-that-wasnt/ https://finance-commerce.com/2018/04/the-transit-revolution-... (They never actually built a real system, though).
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> “People don’t like to wait,” says Mike Stanley, CEO of Transit X. It's true, which is why this system would likely fail in New York. How long are you going to wait for a five-person pod to take you uptown, when you're waiting in line with all these people: https://i.redd.it/dmrfzu0dl3y01.jpg https://i.redd.it/dmrfzu0dl3y01.jpg
- RandallBrown 9y agoOne of my coworkers is in that photo. Is that yesterday?
- pavel_lishin 9y agoSmall world! Yup, as a result of the storm.
- svalorzen 9y agoSome years ago a similar company called Shweeb was doing the same thing with human powered pods. They got $1M from Google as a grant and then disappeared. I was disappointed because I really see myself using this kind of transportation, here's hoping they make it.
- at-fates-hands 9y agoAnybody else read this part: "The support poles will hold large batteries; the pods will park where energy is available and charge while parked." And think, "Wow, this is going to be a huge recycling issue."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pascalxus 9y agoIf i was still living in the City, i know I would want this.