3 ms·
False positive paradox: "The false positive paradox is a statistical result where false positive tests are more probable than true positive tests, occurring whe
by tzs 9y ago
False positive paradox: "The false positive paradox is a statistical result where false positive tests are more probable than true positive tests, occurring when the overall population has a low incidence of a condition and the incidence rate is lower than the false positive rate"
Prosecutor's fallacy: "The prosecutor's fallacy is a fallacy of statistical reasoning, typically used by the prosecution to argue for the guilt of a defendant during a criminal trial".
The false positive paradox is a result. To get to a prosecutor's fallacy or base rate fallacy from it, you have to use the result in a way that involves certain fallacious reasoning.
There's nothing necessarily wrong with using a screening test that the false positive paradox applies to, as long as you recognize its limitations. When you are looking for a needle in a haystack (which is typically when you hit the false positive paradox) it gives you a smaller haystack to search for the needle, but that can still be a big improvement over not using it as long as it has a low false negative rate.
- jessaustin 9y agoThat is simple arithmetic, not a "paradox". Those who can't do that arithmetic will be ill-equipped to use this "smaller haystack" in a sensible or just way. Instead, they will simply arrest the first member of that smaller haystack they find.