3 ms·
I strugle to follow the authors point, but the topic goes to two interesting problems I'd like to pick out to see if there are any opinions on them: 1) Once a
by roenxi 9y ago
I strugle to follow the authors point, but the topic goes to two interesting problems I'd like to pick out to see if there are any opinions on them:
1) Once a person has decided they have enough evidence to form an opinion, they form the opinion then forget the evidence. This makes it excruciatingly difficult to change their minds, because they can no longer check why they formed their original beliefs.
2) Debate will likely be one of two cases:
- A factual debate, where one side who is 'wrong'
- A values debate, where both sides are necessarily focused on different issues
Both of these are very delicate situations where empathy, moderation (as in mildness) and consideration are quite important in getting to a good place. Unfortunately, if participants suspect the audience perception is that they are losing in a factual debate rather than learning about others in a values debate they get very defensive very quickly.
- lhuser123 9y ago> they form the opinion then forget the evidence. It can get even more interesting when memories are there but have been “edited”, making it easier for the mind to rationalize the present opinion.
- TheChaplain 9y agoI get the impression that debate these days is more of a game to see whose opinion wins, rather than debating to see others opinions and reflect on your own in order to jointly come up with a better result.
- AstralStorm 9y agoInstead of the word debate, why not use something better understood, such as discussion instead?