8 ms·
> backdoor reference checks aren’t always considered kosher by everyone ?? These are the most important references. Many excellent candidates won't have a bac
by gumby 9y ago
> backdoor reference checks aren’t always considered kosher by everyone
?? These are the most important references. Many excellent candidates won't have a back connection but when they are possible they can make an important difference two ways: One is the way described here (or, "this person was OK but doesn't sound like they would work out for the kind of thing you want -- that was where they failed with us too."). The other is the opposite, which has happened to me twice: "Oh that person? Look, if you don't take them let them know we'd really like them back" (on a candidate who barely made it through the interview but there was enough something there that we decided to do some background checking. Turned out he was simply nervous in front of people he didn't know and gave a terrible interview.). Without the background check we might have missed an excellent candidate with poor job-seeking skills.
Whenever I get a resume with a school on it that I or one of my colleagues attended I always check. I also once had an amazing candidate with 20 years experience in the lab doing just what we wanted. Their resume said that they had a degree from my schoo in X. I of course looked them up on the alum site and saw they had a degree in Y. Now both X and Y were in the set {Chemistry, Physics, Material Science, Chemical Engineering} so clearly had they simply told the truth it wouldn't have mattered -- the 20 years of experience would have said enough for anyone who actually cared about degrees after all that time. But since they lied...the resume went into the trash and the candidate was never brought in for an interview.
- anothergoogler 9y agoHow do you know that your backdoor reference doesn't personally dislike the candidate for something unrelated to their mutual work experience? Maybe hiring by hearsay works for some people, but I don't trust references, good or bad.
- seunosewa 9y agoThat’s actually an argument for checking more than one reference from each organization.
- dx034 9y agoOr asking the candidate? You can still check if the position of the other person is relevant but it makes sense to not randomly ask people at former employers if there are only 1-2 who can really describe the work they did.
- cascom 9y agoIt is generally understood that candidates must consent to have their references checked. In what part of the application process did the candidate consent to you letting anyone you choose know they are looking for a job?
- RightMillennial 9y agoPardon me if this is a naïve question. Isn't the point of references that they can be checked and verified? Why would you need to obtain explicit consent to contact the contacts when they've been provided? Isn't the consent implicit by virtue of them being supplied?
- abiox 9y ago> by virtue of them being supplied afaik, a backdoor reference is specifically _not_ a reference that was (intentionally) supplied.
- cascom 9y agoYes - and most times candidates will sign some form of blanket consent allowing companies to go beyond the the supplied references, and potentially run a background credit check/investigation. Which I’m by no means saying not to do. But key is getting the candidate’s consent and doing those checks at the appropriate time in the process, so you don’t potentially damage the candidate through your actions
- cwkoss 9y ago> It is generally understood that candidates must consent to have their references checked. Seeing as how there is some debate in this thread, I'd argue that that is not generally understood very well.
- stickfigure 9y agoIt is generally understood that candidates must consent to have their references checked. That's rubbish. It's generally understood that all parties are expected to perform due diligence. What do you think people do with the connection graph linkedin displays? I've interviewed people who were clear that they didn't want their current employer to know that they were looking - that's fine, and easy to respect. But the article describes a former job on a resume; there's no risk you're going to interfere with their current employment by reaching out to mutual contacts. Personally, I hope people look me up through the social network... hell, that's how I find all of my employment.
- mfringel 9y agoIf they're discreetly seeking other employment, you have now blown their cover. A couple of things about that: 1. "If they're looking for another job, they can have no guarantee of secrecy." -- Sure, but is it your job to out someone? 2. "I need a second opinion on their references, just in case they're giving me bad ones." -- So.... what exactly is your threat model, here? "Catfished by a candidate" stories are interesting because they're rare. 3. "If I tell other people they're looking, I can reduce their leverage by making things awkward for them at their current job." -- Hey look! I found the sociopath! Bonus Thing: It's a small industry, and people don't go away. You've now marked yourself as someone who can't be trusted with knowledge about someone's else career choices.
- gumby 9y ago> If they're discreetly seeking other employment, you have now blown their cover. That's a good point, and I took these as a given: the people you call should be people you know very well, and, typically, don't do this until the candidate has advanced to the reference checking phase anyway (why would you waste your friend's time either?)
- stordoff 9y agoThe fact that they are interviewing with a particular company is private information; you have no right to make that public. Also of note is that the article claims that "if I didn’t do my backdoor checks I would have never uncovered the Catfish", but then later states the "fake manager [was] one out of the two people that I knew from Acme Corp". Had she waited 'til that point, she would have discovered the lie without sharing the information with people who don't (ostensibly--as they are listed on the reference) already know it and without relying on woolly information ("no one has heard of him" does not sound like solid proof that he never worked there, particularly if it's a large company).
- desdiv 9y agoIt's easy to spot this Catfish even without any personal connections at Acme Corp. When Catfish provides Jim @ Acme Corp as a reference, but with a non-Acme Corp address for Jim, then that's a huge red flag. You either: 1. Reply with "Please provide Jim's Acme Corp work email address." Catfish won't be able to. The end. 2. Call Acme Corp front desk and get Jim's real phone number. Call Jim. 3. Find Jim's real email on Acme Corp's website. Email Jim.
- hinkley 9y ago> The recruiter was still having trouble getting the Acme Corp reference—which at this point was causing me some minor heart palpitations. Sounds like the author is a piece of work himself. I wonder if he knows how this post paints the work culture at his company.
- aje403 9y agoCan you post where you work so that people reading this know not to apply to your company? Thanks