6 ms·
I don't think I've ever met a person who made a lot of money who'd admit they were rich. The standard these days seems to be: you're rich if you could never wor
by _delirium 16y ago
I don't think I've ever met a person who made a lot of money who'd admit they were rich. The standard these days seems to be: you're rich if you could never work again for the rest of your life, and still live extremely lavishly, with the private jet and yachts and multiple houses. That sets the bar at maybe $100m net worth, which yes, very few people have.
Weirdly, I know people who make around $70k who claim that they're very well off, and seem to actually feel that way. But the people making $300k, $500k, $800k? Invariably they feel middle class, perhaps upper-middle-class, but not even that upper. My guess is that it has a lot to do with social circles and where you live. The guy making $70k who lives in a modest house and whose friends all work at coffee shops feels rich; the guy making $300k who lives on the upper east side of Manhattan and whose friends are all VPs doesn't.
- brianlash 16y agoNassim Taleb makes exactly that point in Fooled by Randomness, which is a terrific read incidentally.
- klochner 16y agoI loved the book, but don't remember that being one of the points.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Locke1689 16y agoMy parents (both physicians) both readily admit they are rich. They also believe the highest tax bracket (their tax bracket) should be raised considerably.
- grandalf 16y agoHow's 80%?
- xenophanes 16y agoHow's 110%? They should give their best effort, yeah?
- enjo 16y agoSee, here's the issue isn't it? How much is enough? I do think the tea-partiers have a point. There most definitely is a level of taxation that greatly reduces people willingness to take risks in the hopes of future wealth. Is it 40%? 50%? 90%? I don't know. I'm just pretty damn sure it's not what we're taxing the wealthy at now. Disclaimer: I would be affected by these tax hikes.
- Locke1689 16y agoI don't know, but that seems like the kind of snarky one-liner that doesn't add anything to the discussion. Because davidw said it so well, I'll just inline quote him here: This is exactly the kind of comment that I feared we would see when articles like this start gaining traction. It's a cheese puff comment: it's got some taste, but it's empty. It has nothing to back it up, no content, no reasoning, no well crafted argument. It's just an empty "rah rah" type of slogan of the type that politicians regularly regurgitate. There is nothing new or clever about the comment, it's the sort of thing that's made the rounds elsewhere 100's of times. Being such a cheap, throwaway comment, it mostly/usually doesn't lead to particularly interesting discussions, as we can see here, despite a few good comments, but more zingers, one liners and similar "go home team!" cheering for one political side.
- grandalf 16y agoI think you misinterpreted my comment. It was intended to be pithy, not snarky. So your parents think that their current tax rate is too low, so I named a higher rate. Why is 80% outlandish? My point was simply that it's a bit silly to bemoan the low rate of taxes today unless you name a rate that you think is reasonable. Clearly you think 80% is unreasonable. If one only thinks a 1-2% increase is reasonable, then stipulate that, rather than making the grandiose claim that taxes should raised considerably. Isn't an 80% rate a considerable increase? The fact is, most people think that 80% is grossly unreasonable. Why? At least there should be a principled argument, not just a rich person bragging (via a complaint) that he/she could afford higher taxes.
- mmorris 16y agoThat's nice to hear. I'm nowhere near the upper tax brackets at the moment, but I like to think that I would be okay (and even encouraging) of the taxes I did face in such a situation. I know many people who make lots of money and are bitter about paying so much tax on it, but very few people who realize that the taxes they pay make a real difference in everyone's lives (especially the lives of those who are less fortunate). Or that the taxes they pay make possible all of the benefits the Federal, State, and local governments offer. Sure, the government may not be the most efficient of entities, but I think it's difficult to make a serious argument that we would be better off without most of the services provided by the various levels of governments, or that they could easily be replaced. And none of these would be possible without some form of taxation (though how the taxes should be structured is up for reasonable debate). While I believe that people should be fairly compensated for their hard work, and that we shouldn't penalize people for working harder, I also believe that it would benefit most people to stop and think about how much their taxes help to make this/any country a great place. *disclaimer: this is mostly about the US, as this is my main experience, but I'd guess most of it applies to (at least some) other nations as well.
- grandalf 16y agoI don't disagree in principle, but I think there is far more value provided by state and local governments than by the Federal government. Roads, hospitals, schools, etc. are all local and state funded. The Federal budget is mostly military spending (the US has no significant military adversaries) and Medicare spending (physicians, pharma and other "caregivers" prey on the elderly and have managed to channel this spending into profits... see Bush's prescription drug benefit/handout to those firms). After that, the remaining 10% of the Federal budget probably makes a lot of sense. Sadly, most of what comes out of everyone's paycheck goes to fund military and medicare overspending.
- diziet 16y agoOut of local spending, almost 30% come from federal government grants. Only 45% of the federal tax base is income tax, and only 15% of the local tax comes from income taxes. Out of federal expenditures, about 45% of them are covered by defense, healthcare and medicare spending.
- tomjen3 16y agoI very much doubt the IRS is going to mind if they send them bigger checks than they have to. So why not do that, rather than demand that the tax level be increased?
- fleitz 16y agoI've always asked that to anyone who advocates for higher taxes yet have never heard of anyone who actually does.
- 2arrs2ells 16y agoAround 400 taxpayers (out of 1.54 million) in Massachusetts opt in to a higher state income tax rate. (see http://dailybabenews.com/article.php?article_id=6842&type=read#continue http://dailybabenews.com/article.php?article_id=6842&typ... ). That said, I think this a terrible argument. Changes to the tax code only have an effect if they take effect across the broad tax base. That said, maybe someone should start a "I'll pay higher income taxes if 1,000,000 people join me" petition on Pledgebank.
- Locke1689 16y agoBecause their argument is not that they, specifically, should pay more in taxes. It is that the highest tax bracket should be taxed at a higher rate. To equate the two is a straw man argument.
- tomjen3 16y agoExactly. I was pointing out their hypocrisy.
- _delirium 16y agoI don't see how that's "hypocrisy". They're arguing that all people in a bracket, including themselves, should be taxed at a higher rate. Arguing that doesn't logically require also being willing to go it alone. Advocating raising taxes on the rich while hiding their own money in offshore bank accounts to avoid those taxes; that would be hypocrisy.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- callmeed 16y agoI don't think it's social circles (although, that might be a by-product), rather parkinson's law kicking in at all levels. The people I know making $70k don't feel rich–but that might be because they are married with kids. If the people you know are single, I could see how that would be different. It's weird–I'm half-way between 70k and 300k now and I feel above middle-class but definitely not rich. We live modestly but have 4 kids and travel a lot.
- _delirium 16y agoYeah, I do know mostly single people making $70k. Some have families, but I can mostly think of reasons why it makes sense to me that they'd still feel well-off. A few live in generally poorer areas; e.g. someone making $70k in Fresno or Fort Wayne is doing well by local standards, and even though they have families to support, they're surrounded by other people who also have families to support who make closer to $50k. A bunch of the rest are immigrants, whose norms are calibrated by a lingering sense that the U.S. is absurdly rich any way you slice it, and that their lifestyle is quite nice compared to family back home. An interesting case are the locals here in Santa Cruz who don't work over the hill in Silicon Valley. There aren't that many good local jobs, and my sense is that the people who make $70k whose social circle is mostly other non-commuting locals feel well off, despite the fact that it's a pretty high-cost-of-living area--- because they know lots of surf bums, coffee shop employees, and people who have to commute from Watsonville because they can't afford to live in Santa Cruz or Capitola.
- enjo 16y agoJust curious: Define "modestly". Do you own your house? Is it a big house? Is it a nice area? I'm always fascinated by the varying definitions of living modestly. I don't mean that as an attack on you in any way. I find that people definitions really do differ quite a bit. What's yours?
- callmeed 16y agoNo. No. Sorta. (crappy neighborhood in a nice general region (CA central coast)) Then again, we're only staying here for 6 months. Wife and I both have used cars ('o6 & '04) that we bought cash. Home furnishings are all used/cheap as we've learned our children tend to destroy things. We don't buy many "nice/expensive" things other than my camera gear and my wife's shoes/clothes.