3 ms·
The complexity of the case is overlooked in the summary. At issue there was the extent to which foster parents are obligated to support the cultural and religou
by gowld 9y ago
The complexity of the case is overlooked in the summary. At issue there was the extent to which foster parents are obligated to support the cultural and religous practices of the legal/biological parents who the children are intended to be reunited with. As with all common law in history, at the borders between clearly right and clearly wrong is a fuzzy area that is addressed messily over time, since it's impossible to know the correct answer for every case in advance.
The problem here was an overzealous case worker -- which is a real issue that needs to be addressed, as you say. And it was addressed by the final ruling, sending a message to future case workers -- not an incorrect law about parenting responsibilities. Making a judgment about the merits of an investigation before the investigation means that you need to decide to not investigate anything.
How often do case workers inappropriately cancel a foster-care arrangement, vs how often to foster parents actually harm foster children?