8 ms·
Abundant water likely to exist under ‘moon rabbit,’ Japanese research team says
- drzaiusapelord 9y agoI wonder if these water deposits are near craters that are in permanent shadow and always below freezing. You could send a relatively small robotic setup that would melt the deep ice into water and use it to form structures on the crater. Now you have a permanent moonbase without bringing in tons of material via rockets.
- dbingham 9y ago...until you try to heat it to a reasonable temperature, the walls melt, and all your atmosphere off gases in to space.
- myaccountforhn 9y agoWater is a pretty useful resource. It is also more weight to bring into space. Having it already available at a location would be tremendously helpful. Using that water to build space igloos would appear to be a poor use of a valuable resource.
- drzaiusapelord 9y agoYou'd have to lay insulation against the ice so you can have a warmer interior, but that's still a pretty good mass savings. You'd use ice for the heavy structural elements and then only lift the lighter stuff.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoThe more pressure you put on ice, the more it wants to turn into liquid. So your "heavy structural elements" can't be bearing too much weight.
- dotancohen 9y agoOn the moon, it could bear six times the mass it would bear on Earth.
- Symmetry 9y agoThe craters full of permanent shadow are at lunar poles and we had already discovered water in one of them[1]. This discovery is that there is probably a lot more water in other places on the moon, but probably far under ground if it hasn't boiled off during the harsh lunar day. [1]https://www.space.com/16222-moon-water-ice-shackleton-crater.html https://www.space.com/16222-moon-water-ice-shackleton-crater...
- vertexFarm 9y agoIt would be a far better use of the water to save it for life support or crack it into hydrogen and oxygen. Regolith can be used to create structures without having to haul everything up out of Earth's gravity well. It's also chock full of aluminum, so that would be easy to make with a nuclear or solar smelter. But water would never be used as a structural material, that would be a tremendous waste.
- narag 9y agoI would have believed that there's some tech that allows an orbiter to detect water under the surface. It seems that such a thing doesn't exist. What's next, droping bombs to study debris and ground waves?
- pacaro 9y agoI don’t know about bombs per se but plenty of stuff has been deliberately crashed into the moon to study its seismic structure etc.
- reaperducer 9y agoI don't remember if the moon was the target, but I recall there was a probe in the last 30 years or so that was deliberately crashed into something just to study the debris that was kicked up.
- Twisol 9y agoYou might be referring to Deep Impact [0], which wasn't even quite that long ago. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Impact_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Impact_(spacecraft)
- kersny 9y agoor LCROSS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCROSS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCROSS
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- themodelplumber 9y agoGoing back further, the original impactor was Ranger, I think. Video just prior to impact: https://youtu.be/dE8pe2EYlZA https://youtu.be/dE8pe2EYlZA
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThe technology does exist it's called radar, and there is already a mission on the books (the Jupiter Icy Moons Explorer, or JUICE) which will take just such an instrument to Jupiter and its moons in the early 2020s. P.S. There's also Europa Clipper, but the funding is less certain: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_Clipper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_Clipper
- tomashertus 9y agoAs I have been growing up and reading about space exploration the narrative had been same: the Earth is special because it has water which allows it to have life. Today it seems like the latest technologies allows us to discover that water in some form is everywhere we look. I believe that it will be the same with life. Today the only known form of life is on Earth and I can’t wait to read about all the discoveries of different forms of life on other planets...
- themodelplumber 9y agoIt'll be fun to learn about shared consciousness, archetypes, etc. If any. Edit: I'm guessing downvoters are low-openness types. But this is a speculative discussion, _that's the point_. In particular this is a question of the level of universality of what we on Earth consider universally-human principles, but we see consciousness outside of humanity as well. So where does it stop?
- chc 9y agoAll speculation isn't equal. There's a difference between informed speculation ("Based on my expertise, I think it's likely X will happen"), philosophical speculation ("What if X happened? Well, here are some obvious consequences…") and idle speculation ("Duuude, what if 'woof' is just dog-language for 'moo'?"). I think people probably didn't see anything to take away from your comment, and that's why they're downvoting, not because their minds are closed to speculation.
- themodelplumber 9y agoHmm, that's a pretty serious writeup about types of speculation for something that isn't exactly off the wall here. If people thought, "there's no takeaway here" and then downvoted, as you said, that goes against the spirit of open-minded discussion. They should simply ask more questions or go find something to upvote. If there exist other life forms with consciousness, the question of whether they share consciousness in the form of shared archetype is not a question with no takeaways. It's important stuff to consider! The implication could be that a life form found on Earth is in some way multi-planetary, for example, and part of a wider consciousness-granting bio-system.
- matte_black 9y agoIf you put a fish in some heated moon water on the moon, could it swim in it and live?
- magduf 9y agoMaybe for a brief time, until the water turned to vapor or if it were in a hermetically sealed container, until the water ran out of dissolved oxygen for the fish to breathe.
- matte_black 9y agoSo for aquatic life, some of these worlds could potentially already be terraformed?
- posterboy 9y agowe potentially already could have but didn't because why would we, what's the use? There's already plenty of fish in the sea, so to speak.
- matte_black 9y agoTo seed life on other worlds?
- jonshariat 9y agoI think the fish also need food. Alge, seagrass, bugs, crustaceans etc.
- magduf 9y agoNot really. For the brief time the fish will survive in an un-enclosed container of water on the Moon's surface, they'll be fine without any food. By the time they get hungry, the water will all be vaporized and they'll be dead.
- delbel 9y agoif there are rocks and gravity, there is water. the gravity crushes the rocks and forces the hydrogen and oxygen out, and it forms water. So basically there is water everywhere in the universe. The "we found water" meme is just tabloid headlines recycled over and over again, much like "voyager leaves the solar system" every year -- wine is good for you, wine is bad for you, antibiotics are causing resistence, etc, etc. Go look at any Popular Science magazine from the 90s and now, the same damn narratives repeated, rephrased, and re-rinsed.
- dredmorbius 9y agoGiven relative elemental frequency in the universe, and propensities to form molecules, water is likely the third most common molecule whhich exists, after molecular hydrogen and oxygen. The second-most prevalent element, helium, doesn't form molecules (to any meaningful extent, if at all). Methane (CH4) likely comes next. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-most-common-compound-in-our-universe https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-most-common-compound-in-ou...
- vertexFarm 9y agoI'd like to see the math on this electrolysis-via-gravity theory of yours. Usually it takes the likes of a nuclear furnace to squeeze oxygen and hydrogen out of a rock. On airless worlds with less gravity than ours, water near the surface tends to sublimate and float off into the great old void. It's extremely rare to find it in places that are relatively easy to access. Even Earth isn't a great source, because all that atmospheric drag and gravity makes water a pain to loft up and out. This new store of ice on the moon is right on our doorstep. Europa is not on our doorstep. Having it on the moon changes all the plans for future manned missions outside Earth's orbit. With hydrogen and oxygen readily available on the moon--and without nuclear reactors and massive chemical processing plants--it suddenly becomes a complete no-brainer to go over there and start making stores of cryogenic fuel for our more ambitious plans. That is if we ever undertake another ambitious plan. New Horizons was amazing, it really was. But it's nothing like a manned flight. People say robotic exploration is just as good, but the intangible things really matter. They really do. Think of just how much the moonshot in the 60s drove people into STEM and got everyone excited about the future. Look at science fiction then vs. now. It went from utopian and focused outward to heavily dystopian, obsessively focused inward. It's so sad. It's impossible to calculate the value of the inspiration of the moonshot, let alone the advances in technology (solid-state computers anyone?). Just imagine how much of a boost it would give our society to go to Mars. This discovery makes it a lot more closer.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoHad we established the first Moon base in 1988 as NASA had on its roadmap in 1970 we would know all about this ice and other aspects of the Moon as well :-). I also agree with Tomas who opined that for a long time it was presented that water was 'rare' and somehow special. And while we can agree that the triple point is pretty narrow set of conditions that have to exist, we now know it flowed on Mars at one time, is probably currently flowing on Europa, and that ice is literally everywhere. Time to rewrite our Science Fiction tropes.
- vertexFarm 9y agoThis discovery of so much more water ice on the moon than previously thought is such a boon for ISRU and future moon habitats and industry if we ever get around to continuing the space race. We could crack lots of cryo propellant, and far more easily than the old plans. The moon could become a huge propellant, fuel, structural materials and life-support depot with a very easy gravity well to get out of--way easier than Earth. That makes it very important for future Mars missions as well. It's easier to stop off at the moon for a bit than to go straight to Mars from Earth. Regolith has all kinds of neat stuff in it, such as aluminum and that legendary helium-3 which may or may not be a miracle fuel if fusion ever breaks even (and we figure out how to do it with aneutronic fuels, which is way harder). The aluminum can be made into solid rockets, which are good enough to get off the moon but damn near useless for anything else because of their pathetic specific impulse. But it would be a great way to get this water off the moon without having to waste much on shipping. If we set up nuclear furnaces we could crack some of the minerals to get oxygen, but it would be so energy-intensive compared to melting ice, and hydrogen is super rare on worlds with easy gravity wells. Hydrogen likes to sublimate off into space and there's practically none anywhere this late in the game. That would be a big bottleneck on ISRU. But all this water ice hidden away near the surface really changes things. Now if we'd only get serious and go nuclear and get people back in space. Check out the always incredible Atomic Rockets by Winchell Chung for great spacecraft diagrams, mission profiles, pdfs of charts and graphs and nomograms and more. It's a treasure trove for space nerds who wish NASA went the way we thought it was going to go in the fifties and sixties. http://projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/ http://projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]