3 ms·
I would love a Surface Hub, I tried to buy one and couldn't because they were only available to 'qualified' customers (something an individual apparently never
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I would love a Surface Hub, I tried to buy one and couldn't because they were only available to 'qualified' customers (something an individual apparently never could be).
Now with 4K (or 8K!) displays it becomes completely credible to replace a white board with one. And the benefits of the shared whiteboard and presence is really solid when working with someone who isn't local.
The software infrastructure investment is immense however. And while I would love to see an open source version of this I doubt such a thing would ever exist. You need a video conferencing component, a drawing/archiving/sharing component, hardware that can accelerate the drawing function to avoid lag, and significant bandwidth to host both video and images being swapped updated in real time.
- mrep 9y agoWhile I agree the benefits of the shared whiteboard sound nice, I much prefer the feel of drawing on a whiteboard over touch screens. Plus, whiteboards are much cheaper.
- rtkwe 9y agoIt's nice until you need to do any remote collaboration with whiteboarding there's not really a good way to allow someone on the phone to interact with people in the room. Even with a camera the remote person has to describe anything they want to add to the whitebaord diagram. I think that's where there's no real substitute for being there in person at the moment in most offices because digital whiteboards have never really caught on.
- Someone1234 9y ago> I tried to buy one and couldn't because they were only available to 'qualified' customers You can order one from CDW right now[0]. They did initially only open them up to Microsoft Partners with a certain level, but that was many years ago now. I will say that a Surface Hub is much more useful when used as part of AD/O365. Since Skype for Business is a major selling point and not really useful to the individual. Using it as a glorified e-whiteboard isn't its strongest feature, it is a fantastic meeting/collaboration tool. [0] https://www.cdw.com/product/Microsoft-Surface-Hub-touch-surface-Core-i5-8-GB-128-GB-LCD-55in/3979032 https://www.cdw.com/product/Microsoft-Surface-Hub-touch-surf...
- basch 9y agoyou can not order one right now, out of stock
- basch 9y agothis got downvoted but its true. you cannot order a 55in surface hub at the moment, from anyone.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOf the two I'd like the 84" one, its got the 4K screen, the 1920 x 1080 screen of the smaller one doesn't allow for a good drawing experience. CDW also claims to sell that one for about 30% over list from the Microsoft site. And while I get the relabeled Teams stuff as Skype for Business I would assume it is also compatible with Skype for humans :-). In my home lab I would use it for collaboration with remote folks, brainstorming, video watching, program planning and parts location storing. In my fantasy world I select a component or assembly I need and it shows the layout of the lab with an arrow indicating where that piece is stored, the last time it was known to be there, and perhaps re-order information. [0] https://www.cdw.com/product/Microsoft-Surface-Hub-touch-surface-Core-i7-8-GB-128-GB-LCD-84/3979037?pfm=srh https://www.cdw.com/product/Microsoft-Surface-Hub-touch-surf...
- mynameisvlad 9y ago> And while I get the relabeled Teams stuff as Skype for Business I would assume it is also compatible with Skype for humans :-). I don't believe it is. Skype and S4B, apart from the common name, have literally nothing in common with each other. Skype for Business is just a rebranded Lync, which is a rebranded Office Communicator. The new board uses Teams conferencing which IIRC is also incompatible with Skype for Business (it's meant to replace it).
- basch 9y agoTeams and S4B can sort of communicate but its more broken than it works. If a user is signed out of teams, but signed into S4B, the message might go to teams instead. Sometimes teams continually fragments S4B messages into new convos.
- nxrabl 9y agoSage2 [0] is one open source option with support for both the remote collaboration and whiteboard components, although it's more focused on larger arrays of average resolution screens. I've used it and it's quite functional, even if not as polished as Microsoft's offering. [0] http://sage2.sagecommons.org/ http://sage2.sagecommons.org/
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOk that looks like a good start!