5 ms·
purports that one party to it has the power to unilaterally interpret it That's not what it does. I think arbitration (except between companies) is dangerous,
by icebraining 9y ago
purports that one party to it has the power to unilaterally interpret it
That's not what it does. I think arbitration (except between companies) is dangerous, but arbitration doesn't mean one party decides, but a third-party (arbitrator).
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y agoThe problem is that the third party is often picked, to some degree, by one of the parties, and there is a perverse incentive between the third party and the party that is picking them.
- icebraining 9y agoThat's why I think they're dangerous, as I wrote. But they're not illogical.
- mindslight 9y agoThat "third party" arbitrator is effectively an agent of one party. There isn't a vibrant market for arbitrators. A consumer-oriented one clearly wouldn't be approved by the industry board, and so couldn't be chosen even if the consumer would pay for it. It's a dog and pony show to conjure a purportedly neutral third party, but that "third party's" ongoing business relies on delivering the company's desired outcome. Hence, agent. Furthermore, the deeper repudiation of meaning is the assertion that the arbitrator's decision is exempt from review by a proper court.
- Matticus_Rex 9y agoThat's true neither in theory or in practice, and the win stats bear it out. Consumers are MORE likely to win in arbitration, not less, and the data do not show systemic bias of AAA or JAMS even for the largest customers.
- mindslight 9y agoCurrent stats sure - the arbitration industry realizes it's still on shaky ground (hence regrouping with 30 day opt out clauses etc). The incentives are still aligned the way I've described, so that's how we'd expect things to progress once its desired regime is more established.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 9y agoNevermind thinking ahead!
- Matticus_Rex 9y agoExcept it's not new, and the stats show it's not what you think it is. You're not thinking ahead -- you're making assumptions based on a lack of knowledge of a complex field you know little about, and consequently reality doesn't look like your assumptions.
- mindslight 9y ago> you're making assumptions based on a lack of knowledge of a complex field you know little about Well, to even form a contract, both parties have to have an understanding of what exactly is being agreed to. So it's more than a bit disingenuous to claim that the real details are just too complex for a non-insider to have an opinion. And BTW, the trend is new enough that individual companies are still shifting between having said clauses and not after getting slapped down (eg CapitalOne), and tinkering with said clauses in an attempt to make them hold up better (eg adding a 30 day opt out period from account opening).
- Matticus_Rex 9y ago> both parties have to have an understanding of what exactly is being agreed to An understanding that they will be undergoing arbitration is enough to satisfy the "meeting of the minds" element, the fact that a lot of people have antifactual opinions about arbitration notwithstanding. >And BTW, the trend is new enough that individual companies are still shifting between having said clauses and not after getting slapped down (eg CapitalOne), and tinkering with said clauses in an attempt to make them hold up better (eg adding a 30 day opt out period from account opening). Yes, and this is primarily because of silly attacks on arbitration, and not because of actual facts. Judges are really bad at looking at facts -- this is one more area where arbitration tends to do far better. The average person loves rent control, too, but that doesn't stop them from being provably wrong.
- gamblor956 9y agoI was an arbitrator before I was a lawyer. I was not an agent of either party, and the consumer won more frequently than did the business. Based on professional observation, consumers/customers (meaning individuals) generally win arbitration cases against businesses. Employees tend to lose. Haven't seen enough B2B arbitration cases to comment on any sort of pattern.